Whoever the next President is, there will be no new dawn for America
In recent weeks many newspapers and websites have been proclaiming that the United States is about to wave a not-so-fond farewell to the Bush Era, and begin afresh on a new, presumably more internationally palatable epoch. Much has been made of how the Republicans have been distancing themselves from the legacy of George W; and of course the Democrats have been doing that for eight years. But how credible is this idea? Will any of the three potential successors to Bush actually change anything very much?
Certainly this seems unlikely if the presumptive Republican nominee, John McCain, wins. McCain is, famously, a ‘maverick’ – that is to say he does not always vote with his party, often taking more liberal stances than most Republican lawmakers (a tendency that is causing him trouble at the moment, though is unlikely to cost him the nomination at this stage).
But McCain s no ‘airy-fairy liberal’. He is pro-life, though he says he would leave the decision to the states (thus washing his hands of the issue and thereby ensuring that it certainly would not be settled either way under his administration). Like all the candidates, he is against gay marriage. Despite having initially opposed George Bush’s tax cuts, he now supports making them permanent.
Most notably, he alone of all the Republican candidates has stood staunchly by Bush over Iraq. He was a very early supporter of the controversial 2007 troop surge, and has explicitly said he has no problem with the idea of US troops remaining in Iraq for the next century. He is equally hawkish on Iran, and would continue Bush and Cheney’s current aggressive route. However, he does oppose the use of torture, including waterboarding, and has said he would close Guantanamo Bay. He has voted for gun control legislation (though he has also voted for pro-gun legislation), was a key part of the McCain-Feingold Bipartisan Campaign Finance Reform Act of 2002 that cleaned up political donations, and voted for the recent (failed) legislation that would have given illegal immigrants a path to citizenship. Nevertheless, especially given the likely presence of Mike Huckabee (the evangelical conservative ex-governor of Arkansas) as Vice-President, McCain would surely at best curb the worst excesses of the Bush era.
Would either of the two history-making Democrats change anything? Barack Obama is vaunted as the candidate of change and hope, but has yet to translate his admittedly impressive rhetoric into solid policy. Worryingly, he does not support universal healthcare as Clinton does, though he would seek to ensure wider health cover. This would hardly address one of the worst scandals in American government. He does, unlike McCain and Clinton, advocate diplomacy with Iran, and, having not been in the Senate in 2003, did not vote for the Iraq invasion, and never supported it. Clinton has tended to swing with public opinion on this one, and remains hawkish on Iran. Both Obama and Clinton would retain the US’s historic support of Israel.
On the domestic front, all candidates have, in one form or another, supported the usual American touchstones such as banning flag-burning by law, the definition of marriage as between a man and a woman and stringent national security legislation (even Obama voted for the 2006 version of the PATRIOT Act).
I acknowledge that, thus far, I have been viewing this from my own, liberal, standpoint. However, even from the conservative side, nothing much will change. Obviously neither Obama nor Clinton would advance more conservative policies than the current administration. McCain is inherently more conservative and might, as I mentioned, have Vice-President Huckabee sitting down the corridor ensuring that his policies remained so. However, he would probably face a Democratic Congress. Moreover he is, judging by his record, not an instinctive staunch conservative, and so it is hard to see him launching legislation that would permanently change the US in favour of conservative ideals, such as a constitutional amendment banning gay marriage.
All of the candidates, whilst likely maintaining interventionist doctrine, would learn from Bush to seek to be a little more multilateral in international action.
Besides all of this, the pernicious influence of special interests and, above all, money, remains in the US, and neither McCain, Obama nor Clinton have proposed drastic action to change this – thus they will remain slaves to it. It is hard to see any of them changing America in any significant way.
