‘Who Are You?’

By Flora Loughridge
In the new television documentary, Who Are You?, artist Grayson Perry turns his attention to the thought-provoking theme of identity and in particular how identity is conveyed through art.
It is not possible to understand an individual’s identity by simply taking them at face value, and yet people have a bad habit of labelling and stereotyping others. Perry observes how it becomes almost too easy for society to categorise characters similar to those he meets on the programme: Jack and John as ‘gay’, Shea as ‘mixed race’ and Jazz as ‘transgender’- flat, superficial readings of complex and significant identities. We must instead probe into the rich inner life of an individual as an attempt to pin down the essence of their character. This is a challenge that Perry faces in using portraiture to crystalise a fascinating lifetime of identity in a single instant.
Perry declares that our identities are works of art in themselves, the “most beautiful and complex” art we can make. In a fast-moving, anonymous world, identity can become so easily lost, hidden or forgotten. The portrait externalises identity in an artistic monument to the self, uncovering what lies behind the deceptive mask that people so often wear.
X Factor and Big Brother contestant, Rylan Clark, is a good example of this. With his flamboyant celebrity personality heightened by the media, his identity has become a “creation for the modern media age” and merely a crafted surface that conceals his ‘real’ character. Indeed, through the camera lens, his raw, honest personality has been lost. Even his birth name, Ross, has been cast aside for an alter ego, and it clearly troubles Rylan to see how easily the public has been taken in by this fake identity.
Perry creates a portrait of Rylan that draws parallels to court portraiture of the Elizabethan age. The portrait miniature was an art form that flourished in England from the sixteenth to the mid-nineteenth century. Miniatures were particularly popular amongst the ‘elite’ classes or the ‘celebrities’ of the day and like medals, were worn or displayed with a sense of pride. Rylan’s portrait, named the Earl of Essex, reminds him of the concept of ‘playing a caricature’ of oneself. Indeed there is a comic distance created between a miniature and its subject, perhaps due to the portrait’s small size, which in this case ironically reduces the big character of Rylan to a six inch piece. Yet its size prompts Perry to make a further compelling comparison of the miniature to the iPhone: both objects play a huge role in the manufacture of the celebrity, particularly modern technology, which often encourages people to create fabricated ‘versions’ of themselves on the internet.

Perhaps the most poignant depiction of identity in the programme is when it is shown in its most fragile state. Perry introduces Christopher, who having been diagnosed with Alzheimer’s, is looked after by his wife, Veronica. The artist explores how families shape identity, but how both family and identity are threatened by external forces, such as this all-encompassing disease. Sufferers are ultimately stripped of their personality and experience the deterioration of who they think they are, whilst their carers also undergo an identity crisis. Veronica describes how she has almost become a part of Christopher, since her identity has been subsumed in providing constant care for her husband. In their portrait, Memory Jar, Perry attempts to capture and hold the memories of their relationship through the use of their family photos. The couple is depicted embracing under a blanket that acts as a protective bubble against the threatening shards of their ‘memories’ that have fragmented around them. In a touching closing statement, Veronica describes the portrait as “amazing” because “it is forever”. Art is powerful since it leaves behind the legacy of immortality and holds our identity in trust.
Identity is the core of who we are, even if it is subject to change over time. Perry takes important components of identity- gender, family, status and power- and places them in a very human context: the characters he meets in Who Are You? confirm identity as unique and personal to every group or individual, in how it is lived or performed. It is not an easy task to convey identity through art, yet an honest visual interpretation through portraiture can be incredibly moving and powerful.
The 14 portraits from the Channel 4 series ‘Who Are You’ are being exhibited at the National Portrait Gallery from 25th October 2014- 15th March 2015.
Photographs: Channel 4
