Where has the rom-com gone?

by Megan Brownrigg
We haven’t struck rom com gold in nearly a decade. The Big Wedding, in UK cinemas from 29th May, needs to make a big impression. Romantic comedies are second date saviours; boys aren’t third-wheeled by Noah from The Notebook and girls escape Die Hard 3, keeping things on safe ground before having to ‘be yourself’ comes in to play.
Despite our love of Pampers and party bags at the time of their release, my generation would still refer to Four Weddings and a Funeral and Notting Hill as staple romantic comedies. It hasn’t been a total wasteland since; Bridget’s big knickers are now comedy shorthand and no Christmas is complete without Love Actually or The Holiday’s quaint Surrey setting. But even these films were made ten years ago. Arguably a degree of time needs to elapse before something becomes a classic, but it took less than a decade for people to associate 10 Downing Street with Martine McCutcheon’s fantastic thighs. The only legacy He’s Just Not That In To You seems to have left is one of self-esteem suicide.
Romantic comedies haven’t vanished, in my opinion they’ve just got worse. Emily Bracken’s HuffPost article, just before the release of Bridesmaids, claimed that romance was dying. Despite travesties such as the commissioning of The Break Up, romance is not dead; if it was, so would be the love of the classics. Bridesmaids failed to be the new Notting Hill because it didn’t want to be. Why make another Five Year Engagement, which only grossed $28 million, when you can market a female Hangover, knowing full well that the male counterpart grossed $467 million? Consequently, rather than Meg Ryan’s sugar-coated smile, we are greeted with a garish image of women with whom you would be clinically insane to mess. Then of course, rather than an orgasmic coffee date, we have ladies defecating in wedding dresses. Despite this scene in Bridesmaids being billed as one of the funniest, I would rather see Rowan Atkinson elaborately wrap a necklace any day.
Unlike many cynics, I would argue that something more archetypal than Bridesmaids could be rapturously received. Take Crazy Stupid Love, a film abundant with romance which elicits laughs through clever twists rather than human excretion. What’s more, when it was screened at my college recently, the belly laughs belonged to the boys: men can survive without toilet humour. Having enjoyed success at the box office, Crazy Stupid Love is testament to the fact that the romantic comedy done well is a bulletproof formula.
The crudeness of Superbad and American Pie has become the standard rather than exception. Just like wearing lycra somehow became normal, we’ve got used to grimacing.Take Pitch Perfect, which despite an incredible accappella cast, resorts to projectile vomiting recalls for laughs. Physical comedy is undeniably effective, but it also screams rather than speaks, forcing the romantic aspects to hit up overtly sexual avenues in order to be heard. Lines such as ‘is it raining, I hadn’t noticed’ may not be the diamonds of romantic screenwriting, but they own a subtlety which the dry humping of Going the Distance does not.
Recently, I tried to watch the romance Safe Haven, but it had received so many one star reviews that my local cinema no longer screened it. Instead I watched Identity Thief which, although hilarious, is a typical American comedy involving vomit, violence and swearing. We need our middle ground back; yes times change, but not this much. To bring the romcom back would be akin to party bags at an adult party: no one is going to say no.
The Big Wedding is in cinemas from May 29th.
