When the world watches, everyone should be welcome 

By Josh Causer  

Less than two months before the 2026 FIFA World Cup kicks off, over 120 civil society organisations (including the ACLU and Amnesty International) have issued a formal travel advisory. It warns that fans attending matches in the United States could face arbitrary detention, invasive device searches, racial profiling, and, in extreme cases, death in immigration custody. 

The advisory describes a “deteriorating human rights situation” in the US. It has been issued in the absence of meaningful action from FIFA, host cities, or the US government. For a tournament whose official slogan is “Football Unites the World,” the irony is difficult to ignore. 

There is, of course, a familiar counterargument. The United States offers world-class infrastructure, a vast commercial market, and genuine footballing passion. Between five and ten million visitors are expected, generating enormous economic activity. The tournament will also span Mexico, Canada, and the United States, making it a rare multinational event across a historically significant footballing region. 

“Football Unites the World,” the irony is difficult to ignore.

Some argue that sport should rise above politics. Fans, they say, should not be discouraged from attending because of a host nation’s domestic policies. 

That argument deserves respect- but it does not hold. 

The risks identified by the ACLU and its partners are serious. They include arbitrary denial of entry, aggressive immigration enforcement, and the suppression of speech and protest. These are not hypothetical scenarios. In 2026 alone, ICE custody has already recorded at least 14 deaths. This is an alarming figure for a year in which we are yet to reach the halfway mark.  

In February, ICE confirmed that its agents would play a “key part” in tournament security. This raises the possibility of enforcement activity within host cities themselves. Those most at risk include fans, players, journalists, and visitors from immigrant communities, racial and ethnic minority groups, and LGBTQ individuals. That represents a significant portion of the global fanbase football claims to welcome. 

FIFA’s response has been characteristically evasive. A spokesperson reiterated its commitment to internationally recognised human rights and pointed to existing frameworks for 2026. But citing policy documents while avoiding demands for concrete guarantees is not meaningful action. It functions more as a liability shield- and the ACLU has said as much. FIFA has leverage over the US government and has chosen not to use it. 

If FIFA cannot ensure that the world is safe to show up, that promise is not aspirational. It is false.

This failure did not begin in 2026. It dates back to 2018, when the USA–Canada–Mexico bid was awarded the tournament. That process introduced human rights criteria for the first time, following controversies surrounding Russia 2018 and Qatar 2022. At the time, it was presented as a turning point. 

In reality, little changed. 

While bidding nations were required to submit human rights plans under FIFA’s 2017 policy, those plans were never made public. FIFA blocked their release. Accountability, it seems, ends where transparency begins. 

By 2026, the question is no longer whether FIFA should have chosen a different host. Relocation is not realistic this late in the process and would create widespread disruption for players, fans, and organisers alike. That decision needed to be made in 2018. 

But focusing on that question risks letting FIFA off too easily. The more important issue is structural: how can this be prevented in future? 

At present, FIFA’s human rights criteria are largely advisory. Bidding nations submit strategies, but there is no independent enforcement, no transparent scoring system, and no meaningful consequences for failing to meet standards. Human Rights Watch has called for these standards to be embedded into hosting agreements, alongside independent and publicly accessible monitoring throughout the process. That should be the minimum for an organisation overseeing the world’s most-watched sporting event. 

Public opinion reflects this urgency. A YouGov poll across 15 countries found that 53% of respondents believe human rights should be a key factor in host selection- second only to safety and security, and far ahead of commercial considerations. The public recognises something FIFA appears to overlook: the right to attend a football match and the right to be safe are inseparable. 

Football’s power to unite is real- but it is not unconditional. 

This summer, in one of eleven American host cities, there will be fans who decide not to come. There will be journalists turned back at the border. There will be families who weigh the risks and decide they are too great. 

The tournament’s slogan promises unity. If FIFA cannot ensure that the world is safe to show up, that promise is not aspirational. 

It is false. 

Image Credit: Earth Photart via Pexels