When it comes to suicide, the press must exercise restraint
The suicide of Gary Speed in November, renowned Welsh Football player and manager, rocked the Football community. A talented player and family man, his death came as a shock, heightened all the more by the mystery surrounding his death – why would such a talented and well liked man take his own life?
His character was praised in the media, across social networking sites and by public figures. Sympathy was expressed for his family; pictures of his sons were released evoking maternal feelings of empathy. And then the speculation began. Enquiries of whether it really was a suicide, fingers pointing at his wife, encouraged all the more by her revelation of the argument she had with her husband earlier that day, questions about his sexuality and other motivations that might have led him to this.
The circus that surrounded his death was too much. The initial celebrations of the life of a great man and questions about what had led him to do this were acceptable and could be seen as being in the public’s interest. But the furore that has continued is overdone, insensitive at what should be the most sensitive time, and leads me to question the ethics of the press.
Our nation’s grim curiosity – that thing inside you which makes you turn your head when you see there has been an accident, or click on that article about a horrific tragedy – is leading our newspapers to function in the same way as Simon Cowell. They exploit every last drop out of a story, get as much money as they can from it, and then move on to the next tragedy.
Speed’s family and close friends have been left distraught after his death and this should be a time for them to come to terms with what has happened and to grieve. With the constant headlines and repeated speculation however they have little chance to do this and although the publicity may satisfy our nation’s curiosity, it hurts those who are already hurting the most, even more.
There is need for suicides to be reported. It is in the public interest to find out the truth behind a major event and a lack of information can lead to rumours, resulting in a warped portrayal of what actually occurred. Opening up information about such sensitive issues as suicide allows people to freely discuss them within our society, which will hopefully help in taking a step towards improving the situation. However this can go too far.
With constant attention which is often extremely positive in order to appear sympathetic, the suicides of public figures can become almost glamorised. Their lives are remembered highly as outstanding and they become untouchable, forever shining rather than just slipping into the background with time. For some desperate people, suicide is then seen as the thing to do, a glamorous way out. This takes away from the harsh reality of suicide, the families torn apart by it and the lives lost. The Canadian Psychiatric Association concluded that when it comes to reporting suicide you must “avoid repetitive and excessive coverage,” in order to prevent such a situation.
Public figures are dependent upon the public’s opinion of them. The 27 club are a group of public people who have all died at 27, with some having committed suicide and some others having died as a result of their own self destruction. Kurt Cobain, lead singer of Nirvana, and a musician who was under intense public pressure and scrutiny, killed himself with a shotgun at 27. Amy Winehouse also died at 27 and although her death was not the result of suicide, it was the result of her self-destruction, something that only started when she became a public figure.
The pressure of maintaining a public persona is overwhelming and the inability for these figures to have a private life, particularly with the technology of today’s society, makes it difficult to cope with. Marilyn Monroe exemplifies this. Elton John sang “and even when you died, the press still hounded you,” revealing the constant and overwhelming attention that was paid to her that eventually resulted in her suicide.
News coverage is a business, and stories about popular figures and horrifying events create interest and sell. However for the media to retain its integrity it needs to make sure it doesn’t over report incidents such as suicide, and must allow public figures a private sphere instead of attempting to penetrate all aspects of their lives. This way the welfare of the figures and society in general will be better protected.
For a BBC tribute to Gary Speed, see this video:Â For a BBC tribute to Gary Speed, watch this video:Â http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-HTDgxgYt3c
What do you think of Joanna’s article? Comment below, or  tweet us @PalatiComment

