‘When I see murder, I cannot stand by’: should celebrities get involved in the issues of ordinary people?

By Nadia Crocker

At the end of October, Quentin Tarantino involved himself in anti-police brutality riots in New York, a move that earned him widespread scrutiny. Addressing rioters upon a podium, he proclaimed: “I’m a human being with a conscience. And when I see murder I cannot stand by. And I have to call the murdered the murdered, and I have to call the murderers the murderers.” This, from a director whose work relies upon the glamorisation of the very violence that he denounces with these words. The president of a police labour union, Patrick J. Lynch, condemned his actions and called for a boycott of the star’s films as a consequence. This event is by no means an isolated example, as it adds to the continuous trend of celebrities manipulating their mass following in order to exert an influence upon social and political movements. But, as we might judge that Tarantino’s actions have added an extra layer of hostility to the proceedings rather than anything else, should celebrities feel the right to involve themselves in situations that affect a reality very different to their own?

Many would consider that the distinction between the life that celebrities live and the lives of the majority of the population disqualifies them from being able to accurately judge the importance and meaning of political movements that affect ‘real’ people. However, whilst celebrities undeniably live in a very different sphere, they are human nonetheless, and to deny them the right to express their opinions is to deny them an essential human right – that of expressing oneself freely. Indeed, it follows that many celebrities are highly qualified to judge social situations, given their talents of perceiving human behaviours. Take Tarantino’s example, for instance. Whilst his films certainly use violence as a source of dramatic energy, in doing so they also illustrate the social consequences of an excess of violence; we are not only shown how the glamorous villains use it to achieve their ends, but also how it provokes emotional distress. Tarantino, by presenting violence to us in indisputable detail, simultaneously presents to us its capacity for harming the lives of all of those that it touches. This awareness of the way that violence works within society would seemingly qualify him to make public statements upon a conflict whose core dispute is that violence, as used by the New York police, is having a negative effect upon citizens’ lives. However, whilst the specific identity of the famous person serves as an explanation for their involvement – given how deeply Tarantino is acquainted with the effect of violence, it is no surprise that he had a strong point of view upon this subject – greater justification for their involvement can be found by examining the exact nature of their involvement, and whether it is likely to further a cause by bringing positive change.

Much of the conflict surrounding Tarantino’s involvement could be seen as having come from the fact that his behaviour easily appears as emotional and unthinking; his comments followed the death of police officer Randolph Holder on the 20th October, after he was shot whilst pursuing an individual who was ultimately apprehended. To many, with fame – no matter how it arises – comes a responsibility to act with a moral awareness, and despite the fact that the director acknowledged the untimely nature of his involvement, reactions understandably took a negative turn as Tarantino made it all too easy for him to be branded as ‘anti-police’. That is not to say that celebrities should be afraid of adding their name to worthy causes – indeed, when they do it is often a catalyst for widespread awareness. It is more that they have a far greater chance of gaining support and thus advancing the cause in a positive direction if their stand appears to be a logical statement rather than a passionate outburst – particularly when it comes to political conflict, whose main hope for resolution is through careful reasoning. This type of celebrity activism can be seen in the example of Elton John, who reacted to the Russian LGBT Propaganda Law denouncing homosexuality at a 2013 concert of his in Moscow by stating that they were “inhumane and isolating”. At the same time, he had resisted calls to carry a boycott of Russia in protest at this same legislation. By avoiding the impassioned action and replacing it with a comment, this demonstrates how he had carefully considered the precise terms of the laws. It was then reported on 24 September 2015 that in response President Putin had telephoned John, inviting him to meet in the future to discuss LGBT issues. Whether the President’s proposition was sincere or not, we could consider the fact that the head of Russia reportedly acknowledged a need for considering the issues as representing progress – progress that arguably would not have occurred had Elton John simply revolted.

However, whether a celebrity is justified or not in making a political stand, we must always remember them as human individuals, who are just as prone to a lack of precise judgement, or to making judgements based upon emotion rather than fact and reasoning, as the rest of the world. When it comes to a favourite celebrity becoming involved in a cause, our emotional attachment to a favourite film or song of theirs could mean that we’re inclined to senselessly support a cause without considering the specific situation. With Tarantino’s case, whilst he can certainly be held up as a figure of personal expression – it is a risk for any high-profile individual to make statements upon contentious matters – it is up to us to operate our discretion to decide upon which side we agree with. After all, each conflict is only a conflict because of the opinions of people like you and I, and whilst celebrities might advance (or regress) the conflict, it is us who will live and breathe the consequences.

Photograph: Sir Mildred Pierce via Flickr