When does copyright become copywrong?

Swartz

by Jonny Bowers

On 11th January Aaron Swartz, Co-founder of www.reddit.com and general internet pioneer allegedly committed suicide. Swartz, a self-confessed sufferer of depression, had apparently taken his own life under the pressure of being charged with thirteen counts of felonies related to the downloading of several thousand articles from the journal database JSTOR through an MIT account. These charges potentially held decades in prison for Swartz and after his death there have been many allegations about the case being handled badly by the prosecution.

Since Swartz’s death, internet activists have been calling for reform to the legislature and laws which govern what can and cannot be done with information downloaded over the internet. Several of the charges Swartz faced were classed as “wire fraud”; a federal offence in the US based on 140 year old legislation.

At Durham University, one of the most commonly used databases for essay writing is the aforementioned JSTOR. Palatinate looked into their terms of use and found that much of the research Durham students, and indeed lecturers, would normally carry out could violate this. Simply downloading an article and emailing to a friend could, in theory, get you into trouble, as could posting it to DUO or handing it out when giving a presentation.

“Several of the charges Swartz faced were classed as “wire fraud”; a federal offence in the US based on 140 year old legislation.”

Other databases have similar restrictions; Firstsearch states that ‘copying in excess of one copy… is prohibited’ meaning that even printing out a journal twice would in theory lead to ‘injunctive relief to stop any unauthorised use of such data’. This could imply potential prosecution on similar grounds to Swartz.

However, the likelihood of this relating to normal activities of millions of researchers around the globe is small. Recently JSTOR have released a statement saying that the Swartz case was one they had ‘regretted being drawn into from the outset’ and that JSTOR settled any civil claims they may have had against Swartz when he returned the papers he had downloaded in June 2011.

Despite this, next time you are in the library downloading the latest paper for your essay, or receive a handout from your lecturer containing parts of a journal, think – is this legal? Should it be?

Photograph: Mike Licht, Sage Ross