“What’s the point?” interview with Durham alumna and Green Party co-leader Carla Denyer

By Abigail Tobias

Green Party co-leader Carla Denyer has had quite a year. With a historic 2024 election where the party quadrupled its seats – including Denyer herself winning Bristol Central over from Labour – she also made Durham history by being on the University Challenge team that beat Queens College Cambridge.

Denyer has returned to her alma mater as an expert in her own right – delivering a talk at Durham University Business School. “From engineering in Durham to politics in Westminster: trying to fix the world faster than one wind farm at a time”.

A St Chad’s mechanical engineering alumnus, Denyer, lights up as she discusses returning to Durham: “I spent about an hour and a half walking around in the sunshine late yesterday afternoon”. She quickly hastens to add with a laugh, “I have lived here before, though – I know that 21 degrees and sunny is not normal up here”.

The day is considerably sunny for Durham and we discuss how much easier it is to romanticise the city when you’re not trudging through the rain to the Billy B.

She does seem less nervous as she tells me about walking through her favourite haunts of the city, “I went to visit my old college, Chads, and walked down to the end of the Bailey, along the river and then went for a quick drink in the sun at The Head of Steam”. Does she miss the summers in Durham? “Oh, definitely”.

At the time I’m interviewing Denyer, council elections are fast approaching – leaflets and doorknockers are becoming a frequent feature of living in Viaduct – and so I am keen to talk to her about student voting, and her time in Westminster.

Renters’ rights have been a large part of Denyer’s platform; “I have been campaigning on renters’ rights for over… well 10 years, for as long as I’ve been a politician” and, being an MP for Bristol Central, she’s attuned to the issues students face in the private rental market. “It’s a really big issue in Bristol as well,” she tells me after I offload some landlord horror stories and the struggle students go through advocating for their rights, “you can wait 6 months for a repair and then you think… well, I could take it to housing court, but I’m moving out soon. As a result, landlords can get away with the very poor-quality homes”.

I have been campaigning on renters’ rights for over… well 10 years, for as long as I’ve been a politician

“I was really pleased shortly after getting elected MP to secure a seat on the Rental Rights Bill Committee. I put forward loads of amendments, a lot of them on affordability including introducing rent controls, which the government strongly opposed, so that hasn’t passed and unfortunately isn’t going anywhere”. Then she gives me a small smile, “at least for now”.

It’s clear to see where her passion for affordability comes from as she tells me she was only able to afford her one-bedroom flat after her granny left her some money. “It is wild that I’m in my late 30s and most of my friends that own their own homes have only managed to if they’ve inherited money”, she sighs. “That is not how we should be deciding who deserves to have a secure home”.

Her work on the bill has also revolved around improving rental housing for disabled renters – making it an implicit part of any tenancy agreement that landlords are responsible for reasonable adjustments to the home as opposed to the onus being on disabled individuals to fight for it. Whilst the amendment isn’t going forward exactly how Denyer proposed, she was heartened that the Minister did acknowledge that Denyer had highlighted a problem: “he has committed to looking into trying to fix that problem in another way and I’ve since had meetings with him about that. So that is a reassuring early sign that as a Green MP, even though we’re not in government, we can push to get improvements.”

It’s wild that most of my friends that own their own homes have only managed to if they’ve inherited money

As I’m keen to tackle the issues that matter to Durham students, I draw her attention to the discourse dominating the higher education sector: Freedom of Speech and No Platforming. Durham is no exception with a Union debate shut down on the Israel-Palestine conflict due to protest, controversy over invited speakers, and all of this becoming a Twitter (sorry, X) war.

“My guiding principle is the paradox of tolerance. By being more tolerant you can create a more intolerant society”. She gets out the phone to double-check the philosopher in a relatable brain fog moment. “Karl Popper! I was going to guess Karl Popper” she exclaims.

“The line for freedom of speech is actively inciting hatred or anger at a part of society, but there’s still a balancing – there’s a difference between expressing hatred and anger and expressing a view on policy.”

With Labour having scrapped the Conservatives Higher Education Freedom of Speech Bill, how does Denyer think universities should be tackling this issue?

“I struggle to see how it could be nailed down and it would have to be principles of decision-making – it has to be up to universities, and I feel nervous about the Government telling universities what they can and cannot say”.

In terms of the protesting of the debates and speakers, she’s firm and unambiguous: “They’ve got every right to protest debates – freedom of speech means freedom to protest as well.”

“It’s an area where the Green Party has quite a different perspective to the other parties; we see the value of protest and the right to protest as a healthy part of democracy. Some so-called free speech advocates seem only to want their person on the platform but not want people to say that’s wrong.”

We see the value of protests and the right to protest as a healthy part of democracy

Her thoughts on student protest seem a brilliant opportunity to discuss what I finally want to cover about student political action, the disillusionment students feel about voting as a vehicle to make change.

“I totally understand feeling, ‘What’s the point?’” she doesn’t hesitate to tell me. “When I was a student here at Durham, I was not politically engaged: I wasn’t a member of the Green Party, I didn’t vote in the local elections because I was a campaigner on climate and civil rights, and I had no faith in party politics as a way of achieving change. So, when I say I understand people who feel like that, I’m not arbitrarily saying that. I’m saying I used to be that person.”

It does seem to be a fairly large leap to go from not voting to being a leader of a political party. “For me it was only through meeting members of the Green Party a few years later, through some of the campaigns I was involved in, that I realised the Green Party was quite different. We are fundamentally grassroots and member-lead and opposed to the hierarchical top-down organisation structure of the other parties,” she tells me. “[The Greens] was an organisation I felt that I might want to not just vote for, but be a part of”.

Her message to Durham Students about enacting change? “The point at which I realised that whilst there is absolutely nothing wrong with protest and campaigning, I might get more of the kind of change I want to see in the world by helping to get Green party candidates elected, than by spending my life writing to MPs from other parties asking them to do the right thing on each individual vote or bill”.

After a fair amount of time cross-questioning Denyer and knowing that she’s crunched for time, I’m keen to finish by bringing her back to where it all began. What does she miss most about her time at Durham? “I quite miss formals, to be honest – they don’t happen very much in life after university so make the most of them in all their weirdness”.

A very Bailey answer; fitting for a Chad’s alumni.

Image: Carla Denyer ©House of Commons/Roger Harris https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/ (cropped)