What’s going wrong with KATSEYE?

By Saskia Fellowes

As the Beautiful Chaos tour wrapped up at the end of last year, global girl group KATSEYE have marked the occasion with the official release of their new single ‘Internet Girl’, to mixed responses. Despite its catchy melody, many have found the repeated “eat zucchini” line off-putting, and switching the line “I’m getting out of here”, a popular part of the live performances, to a baby voice was the icing on the cake. All of this has led many fans to look back over the group’s tumultuous formation – the blood, sweat, and tears that were put into their intense training period – and ask, is this really what it was all for?

For those unfamiliar with the Netflix documentary Pop Star Academy: KATSEYE , it follows the collaboration between American record label Geffen, and Hybe, the company behind massive K-pop bands such as BTS, as they put together girls from around the world in the hopes of creating the next big group, with a Korean-inspired training programme but global appeal. Across the series, we saw the girls undergoing intense training in singing and dancing, some for up to a year, before being informed, despite prior insistence that this was not the case, that they would be entering a survival show where they were pitted against each other in fan voting. There’s no denying that it’s a difficult watch. The young trainees (one of whom is only fourteen) were subject to incredibly harsh criticism from their teachers, cruel online comments picking them apart, physical exertion that often caused injuries, and were lied to several times in the name of entertainment. All of this eventually culminated in KATSEYE, who released their debut EP SIS (Soft Is Strong) in 2024, and Beautiful Chaos in 2025. Despite their apparent success, with 37 million monthly listeners on Spotify (as of January 2026), enormous festival crowds, and two recent Grammy nominations, something is lacking. Given the intense competition and coaching of Dream Academy, it’s obvious that the six members selected for the group are incredibly talented vocalists and dancers, but there are major problems that could mean them soon fading into irrelevancy.

‘Artists need an identity for listeners to understand them as. We need to understand their purpose. Yet KATSEYE don’t know who they are’

Despite their unique position in the market – almost K-pop, but not quite – they don’t have any clear identity. Across their small discography, they have very different sounds; this alone is not an issue as diversity is essential for musicians to remain fresh and relevant in the fickle landscape of pop, but it becomes a problem when there isn’t a strong through-line of artistic identity. To give a strong example of this, Taylor Swift has very distinct sonic eras, but always retains her identity as the songwriter with an unbreakable belief in love; this core self is always clear, even though Fearless, Reputation, and Folklore all sound completely different to each other. Artists need an identity for listeners to understand them as. We need to understand their purpose. Yet KATSEYE don’t know who they are. Their diversity is a key selling point, as they have been marketed from the start as a global girl group, but they feel like six individuals with no obvious reason for making music together. 

Emphasising their diversity is also starting to fall flat now, as their new song ‘Internet Girl’ is made up of vocals so auto-tuned that it’s impossible to tell which member is singing which part of the song. Each of the members have strong singing abilities, yet their unique voices cannot be heard. What they should be doing is further highlighting their diversity as a strength, like with Dani’s Spanish bridge in Daniela. Bringing elements of their different languages and cultures to the music more would help solidify this part of their brand.

The main critique being wielded against them at the moment is the poor songwriting, which is so blatantly aimed at creating a moment on TikTok instead of good music. In spring 2025, ‘Gnarly’ gave KATSEYE their first entry on the Billboard Hot 100. Although it was immediately met with backlash from fans, it quickly became an online sensation, in equal parts derided and loved for its absurd lyrics, including “hottie, hottie, like a bag of Takis”. The popularity of this has clearly led their label to lean further into this style, with ‘Internet Girl’ feeling less like a song and more like an amalgamation of bizarre lyrics begging to become a trending TikTok audio, and fans are seeing through this obvious ploy for virality at the expense of good music. While this songwriting technique may produce fame and money in the short-term, it will eventually damage them by leaving the group without any artist integrity or legacy.

Aside from ‘Gnarly’ and ‘Internet Girl’, most of their discography is lacklustre. ‘Debut’, ‘My Way’, and ‘Tonight I Might’ are fun tracks, but feel somewhat dated and juvenile with their clichĂ© lyrics about friendship and confidence on a backdrop of very 2010s melodies and production – Ă  la Fifth Harmony and Little Mix. Songs like ‘Gabriela’ and ‘Gameboy’ may be better, but are lacking in originality. The highlight of their catalogue is ‘Touch’, an upbeat and catchy K-pop infused moment which is simple but effective.

‘KATSEYE have strong redeeming qualities, so I can only hope that they are able to fix their problems and avoid the graveyard of forgotten attempts at global girl groups’

In spite of their flaws, KATSEYE are certainly not doomed yet. They are still a new group, so they have time to improve, especially with a devoted fanbase to support them along the way. A lot of their fans came from the Netflix show which documented their hard work and backstories, or from the survival show where fan participation made them feel invested in the future of the group. Their close bond with their fanbase is a real strength of KATSEYE’s, one which they should continue to cultivate. Their social media presence, which comes across as fun and authentic and not like the celebrity accounts which just exist to sell you something, craft an image of KATSEYE as cool and trendy, so they appeal to young people. This was hugely helped by their appearance in the viral Gap jeans advert. While celebrity ad campaigns usually make them look like sell-outs, this came out just weeks after the Sydney Sweeney American Eagle advert which saw a lot of attention for all the wrong reasons; after the ad was criticised for its creepy discussion of a white woman having “great jeans/genes”, the KATSEYE “Better in Denim” ad felt like the perfect response, highlighting diversity as the group danced to Kelis’ ‘Milkshake’. With 60 million views on YouTube, it’s clear that this was a great move for the group, endearing them to young people. 

KATSEYE have strong redeeming qualities, so I can only hope that they are able to fix their problems and avoid the graveyard of forgotten attempts at global girl groups. In 2026, I would love to see them take on board the criticism they’ve been receiving and put their talents to good use.

Image: Wikimedia Commons