What’s cooking in Uncle Sam’s Kitchen?

By Matthew Beebee

The case of the Boston Bombing has developed quickly. Within four days of the devastating bomb attack, killing three and injuring around 300, two suspects were publically identified by the authorities. Tamerlan Tsarnaev was shot and killed in a firefight the following day. His younger brother Dzhokhar, who fled the incident, was discovered injured, sent to hospital and has subsequently been charged.

Now the investigation has turned to motive. Although the two are of Chechen origin, the attack was quickly dismissed as having any links to the Chechen independence movement; besides, Tamerlan was a permanent resident in the US and Dzhokhar is a US citizen. Similarly, attacking America would have served very little purpose to the cause of independence. The Chechen separatist movement itself condemned the bombing as an act of terrorism.

The two suspects are also Muslim, and reports point to the older brother in particular becoming increasingly radicalised. Suggestion has been made that the Russian Federal Security Services believed Tamerlan had links to radical Islam and asked the FBI to investigate, but this investigation came to nothing. However, officials claim that the confession of Dzhokhar indicated the attack was religiously motivated. It remains unclear whether the source of this radicalisation was from within the US or from outside sources.

Whether the source is domestic or international, the US faces a problem. Either US residents are being radically influenced by external agents and returning to the US to practice this radicalism, or there are anti-American versions of radicalism within the US itself.Pressure Cooker

There are fears that the brothers are linked to a wider network. Although the attack was carried out using a pressure-cooker bomb, which does point to lone action, al-Qaeda is known to have published an online magazine aimed at British and American youngsters detailing “how to make a bomb in the kitchen. However, this is far from conclusive evidence that the brothers were part of a wider Jihadist movement. Al-Qaeda themselves have claimed no responsibility for the attack.

All this leads to a rather awkward and puzzling conclusion: this was the attack of two ‘lone wolves’ influenced by radical Islamism from an unknown source, either domestic or foreign.

The Boston Bombing is not the first domestic terrorist attack. Native-born Americans, with domestic grievances, have caused America to suffer several terrorist attacks. It was initially speculated, and could still be the case to a lesser degree, that the Boston Bombing was the result of disenchantment with the American lifestyle; religion merely added fuel to fire.

The most infamous domestic attack is the 1995 Oklahoma City Bombing that claimed 168 lives following the bombing of a federal office. The 1996 IED explosion at the  Atlanta Olympics was particularly shocking, given the massive world attention focused on Atlanta at that time. Both of these attacks were the expression of domestic grievances influenced by an extreme right-wing political ideology and Christian fundamentalist belief. Initial speculations pointed to a similar ideology at Boston, given the attack took place around Patriots’ Day and the day federal income-tax returns must be filed.

The outcome of Oklahoma is particularly interesting when compared with Boston. The Oklahoma bombing led to the passing of the Antiterrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of 1996, which tightened the standards for habeas corpus, and passed legislation to increase security around federal buildings.

Boston could too lead to similar changes in the law. The Cyber Intelligence Sharing and Protection Act (CISPA) is a proposed law to allow government access to internet traffic that has already passed through the House of Representatives. Tighter laws could be passed that ensure greater security presence at large public or sport events.

A lot of debate has been made about information posted by the Boston suspects on social media that could have raised concerns; similarly much debate will be made about how much of a hindrance or help social media was to catching the suspects and spreading information. Would laws such as CISPA help to intercept criminal behaviour such as the Boston Bombing? Would it prevent the spread of information on such events? These are questions American lawmakers will have to answer in the weeks and months that follow.

For now, the mystery over the true nature of the Boston Bombing motive is the most pressing, and perhaps the most important, development that will come of this attack.

Illustration from Svenska Familj-Journalen