What makes The Great Gatsby just so great

8599201079_c97bb9ed10_o

by Catherine Malpass

The Great Gatsby’ is undoubtedly one of the greatest novels in American literature and of all time. With the new film version out just out, and amongst all the Hollywood glamour, it is easy to lose sight of the beautiful prose of F. Scott Fitzgerald that has inspired readers for decades. The novel is essential reading material for its pure beauty, and also so you can join in all the conversations concerning film hype when the film is eventually released!

It’s difficult to know where to start with this novel and that is part of its inherent force. To provide a basic synopsis, the novel centres around Jay Gatsby from the narrative viewpoint of Nick Carraway. Gatsby, from poor origins, meets and falls in love with Daisy in his youth. After he is drafted into the war however, Daisy marries someone else. Gatsby then rises to wealth and spends the remainder of his life vying once more for the love he lost. Cue the extravagant parties thrown by the man whose name is on everyone’s lips – all, we eventually find out, for the love of a good woman. This mirrors a similar story in Fitzgerald’s own life, which perhaps explains why the text is quite so emotionally engaging and so centred upon the enigma that is Gatsby, despite him not being the actual narrator.

A relatively unknown fact is that ‘The Great Gatsby’ wasn’t immediately popular when it was first published. The novel, commemorating the extravagant American jazz age, was initially rejected by both British and American readers. Only in successive years since its publication did Fitzgerald’s masterpiece reach an almost cult status. But what has made it so popular?

Firstly, the novel leaves us questioning; taking us on a journey through a maze of personal relationships, thickened by the revelation of past secrets. Nick Carraway, the novel’s narrator, is the perfect orchestrator of suspense. He presents us with a form of dualism – caught between the poles of disgust and attraction to the gaudy Gatsby parties, wavering between sympathy and judgement towards his fellow characters. The most famous example of this in the novel is the incident in which Carraway builds up a mythical portrait of the great Gatsby, only to fail to recognise him upon their initial meeting. As a reader, we are led by Carraway to uncover the final tale of events. Yet there is one question on our lips throughout the entirety of the novel – are the blind leading the blind? We wholly want to believe what we are reading, shy away from certain parts, yet it is Carraway who decides our fate and journey that we take as a reader.

For a modern audience, Fitzgerald’s work is also in keeping with a very current topic of conversation, that of the economy. Set in a post First World War America as it rises to the status of an industrial powerhouse, Fitzgerald discloses the ugly economic realities for many Americans. In ‘The Great Gatsby’, Fitzgerald fixes his novel around a social stratum that quite simply defines the ‘haves’ and the ‘have-nots’. Gatsby as a character may live out the American Dream, defying this social hierarchy as he rises from poor boy to wealthy – but at what cost? In his financial and credential success, he loses out on Daisy. The dream, alongside many other things in ‘The Great Gatsby’, is not at all like we would have it seem.

With contextual issues aside, one cannot deny the intrinsic magnificence of Fitzgerald’s work. The novel itself is short, which makes the ground it covers feel much more intense. Fitzgerald crafts passages that are so absurd they’ll make you laugh, and in the next breath scenes that are so heart-breaking, you may just cry. The novel desperately holds the past as a centrifugal force for its contingency, as Carraway says ‘so we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past.’ No one can escape the definition and effect that the past holds upon the present.

Lastly, the novel, for me, forms one of the best didactic openings in fiction. The opening aphorism certainly acts as an apt precedent for the incredible remainder of the novel, as Carraway recalls his father’s words – ‘whenever you feel like criticising anyone […] remember that all the people in this world haven’t had the advantages that you’ve had.’

With lines like that, many have argued that film and theatre adaptations of Fitzgerald’s artful prose, will always fall short of the original novel. Yet with the release date for the film now set back to next summer, only time will tell.

Photography: Flickr, Bill McIntyre