What makes Durham ‘different’?

by Daniel Johnson

If like me you’re coming to the end of your years at Durham, you’ve probably encountered what is often touted as the ‘Durham Difference’. A mainstay of the University’s marketing exercise, it is supposed to encompass all that is brilliant about Durham; a devilishly daring turn of phrase to describe this quaint old place.

A distaste for overly crude advertising aside – after all, it is the logical by-product of our modern university system – it might be worth seriously considering what this ‘Durham Difference’, if anything, actually is.

First, let’s take the University’s definition. Admittedly, it’s a vague one. The Vice-Chancellor himself wrote in a pamphlet: “we all have an obligation to ensure it – whatever it is – continues to provide the inspiration and education which will prepare future generations of students”.

The ‘Durham Difference’ thus encapsulates the University’s academic prowess (a recent invitation to join the Russell Group was greeted with particular fanfare) as well as its extra-curricular and cultural achievements. Hence the obsession with promoting ‘Experience Durham’, the twin pillar of the University’s marketing axis of evil.

Maybe that term is a bit cynical. There is much about Durham which makes it an excellent university, if not different in the way that Chris Higgins suggests. We can be proud of the fact that Durham is one of the top achieving universities in the country.

A quick glance over recent university league tables neatly illustrates the point. We’re the third best in the country according to the Sunday Times, and frequently sit at the summit of the tables for subjects ranging from English to Physics.

But does this make us different? Arguably not. Instead, it makes us one of a small cohort of universities seeking to unseat Oxford and Cambridge from their near-millennia of dominance.  You could be forgiven for seeing ‘Durham Difference’ as a buzzword, little more than a vacuous branding tool.

One former Palatinate editor wrote a couple of years ago that the Durham difference is “that we compete”. There may be some mileage in this. In 2011/12, over 6,000 students competed in college sport, in more than 5,000 fixtures. (Although there should really be a disclaimer if these college sport statistics include darts and pool).

Our competitive edge isn’t merely confined to sport. Durham’s debaters on Palace Green frequently reach the final stages of international competitions, and DUCK seems to be one of the best in the country at taking other students money for forays or ‘expeditions’ abroad.

Maybe then the difference about Durham, and there’s not really an eloquent way of putting this, is that people just seem to do stuff. Things that don’t just revolve around their degrees. Things that are fun, fulfilling, character-building and CV-enhancing in equal measure.

Students at other UK universities get involved in all kinds of stuff outside of their degrees. But Durham students’ dedication to spending enormous quantities of time involved in clubs or societies, often at the expense of academic work, has to be up there with the very best.

People seem to have turned getting involved in sport, theatre, music, or maybe even journalism into something which is at the least equal to academic work. I see no reason not to celebrate and embrace this as one of our defining characteristics.

For those who had college spirit firmly embedded in their veins way back in freshers’ week, fruitful careers in JCR politics and bureaucracy duly followed. For those who began to find the whole concept somewhat wearisome, there’s a whole plethora of societies whose ranks swell with college sceptics and flourish as a result. And then perhaps there are those fence sitters, who enjoy a bit of both.

The key point is that while some of this may be facilitated by the University, so much of it functions more effectively and successfully when it runs independently and autonomously.

I’m almost certain that the University Executive Committee will take little notice of this commonly-made plea. But it should begin to fathom that its attempts to monopolise and use for its own purposes the societies and colleges which do make Durham genuinely ‘different’, would be entirely self-defeating. If students are to truly ‘Experience the Durham Difference’, then it seems right that they find out what it is for them, and on their own.