What is national sovereignty?

By Tom Mitchell 

“Whilst Parliament has remained sovereign throughout our membership of the EU, it has not always felt like that”. Having danced around the fringes of the matter for the best part of two years, it was thusly in July 2018 that Theresa May’s Brexit White Paper confronted what was simultaneously the most powerful and the most nebulous argument involved in the Brexit debate.

Faced with the presumptuous accusation from Remainers that those of a pro-Brexit disposition were motivated by racist prejudices, the Leave campaign latched onto the concept of “sovereignty” to describe their intentions.

They characterised sovereignty as everything Britain would gain by leaving the EU, transforming the term into an excellent brush with which to tar Remainers as unpatriotic. Indeed, discussions centring on the term sovereignty were often accompanied with other pejorative terms, such as “surrendering” or “eroding”.

In the end, the word became all encompassing, with Brexiteer Daniel Hannan proclaiming that “immigration and the economy (…) are really about sovereignty.”

Political scientists have long distinguished between “real” sovereignty, and “theoretical” sovereignty. The former is the degree of control that a nation exercises over its own destiny, the latter is purely symbolic. Britain, therefore, has forfeited real sovereignty for theoretical sovereignty.

The UK prospered in the EU, with a low rate of unemployment and plenty of foreign investment. With the EU, the UK more effectively countered terrorist threats and climate change.

The UK has decided to forfeit this, to ‘make our own laws’. Given that the UK already controlled 98% of public expenditure, this seems like a heavy price to pay. The distinction between real and theoretical sovereignty is thus key to understanding the relative merits of remaining in, or exiting, the EU.

Image by UK Parliament via Wiki Commons