What is better for a footballer: winning trophies with multiple clubs or being a one-club legend?
By Rob White
Harry Kane has recently achieved a remarkable feat, scoring his 200th Premier League goal and becoming Tottenham Hotspur’s all-time top goal scorer.
He solidified his position in striker royalty by becoming only the third player to reach 200 Premier League goals, alongside greats Alan Shearer and Wayne Rooney. Yet, rather than the complete celebration of his career to date with a view to what he could still potentially achieve, the milestone has led to renewed calls for him to seek a move in pursuit of a major trophy.
In one sense, it is sad that Kane’s achievement has led to a certain amount of negativity about what might have been had a move to a different team already been sought. But a second question arises, what is better for a footballer: winning trophies with multiple clubs or being a one-club legend?
Loyalty is powerful when it comes to football, but it is seldom demonstrated by both club and players alike. For the fan, it is everything. Being wholly synonymous with a club is somewhat a fairy-tale for many and winning for that team is worth more than potential greater success elsewhere.
As Liverpool legend Steven Gerrard described in interview, “If I win a couple of trophies at Liverpool, it’ll mean an awful lot more to me than if I win ten at Chelsea or Inter Milan or Real Madrid. It always means more when you win for your people.” Yet it is levelled at Kane that he has so far been unable to find the success that Gerrard had in his career.
Loyalty is powerful when it comes to football, but it is seldom demonstrated by both club and players alike
Despite having two League Cup runners-up medals, being a Champions League finalist and coming so close to glory at Euro 2020, he has been unable to triumph in these finals. Ultimately, in a team game, it is these trophies which are the most craved. But, as proven in recent years, Kane has come within inches of silverware and a move away from Spurs is no guarantee of winning a domestic title. Nor does it prove him to be a better player.
It is unquestionable that Harry Kane is a world class striker. With or without a team trophy, Kane deserves the plaudits for his individual brilliance and dogged loyalty, more so than has been shown by some media outlets in recent days. That is not to say that a player such as Jack Grealish does not warrant respect for being prepared to move from his boyhood club to a bigger side to strive for success. Nor is it to say that it is always the right choice to stick with a club.
Had Kane played for a team in the EFL, a move would have been warranted, as he has the capability to achieve at the highest level. But Spurs are a top six side, have been challenging for silverware in recent years and were they to win a trophy, it would not come as too great a surprise.
Yet even if he were to fail in this endeavour of silverware, his position in Tottenham Hotspur and Premier League history is secure and cannot be tarnished by specious claims of a lack of ambition. Indeed, it is Kane’s enduring popularity with non-Spurs fans that is testament to, not only his character, but his diligence towards club and country. It is ultimately these fans who will carry his legacy of being one of the all-time greats, not his trophy success.
Kane’s career to date has been incredible and for him, being a one-club legend with a chance of silverware, albeit as slight outsiders to others, should be worth more than seeking a transfer and potentially achieving elsewhere. Indeed, it could be the case that Spurs are challenging again soon.
Kane deserves the plaudits for his individual brilliance and dogged loyalty, more so than has been shown by some media outlets
Football can transform in such an extraordinarily short space of time. Anything is possible, as proven by Arsenal exceeding expectations in the Premier League this season. With plenty of seasons left in the tank, it would not be outrageous if Kane were to be successful with Spurs in the near future.
This possibility means a move away from his boyhood club is not warranted, nor would it necessarily prove him to be a better player than he already is. Rather, it is his very commitment to Spurs which is a key component of his legacy in the making, which should be the real celebration of this achievement.
As the adage goes, “Play for the name on the front of the shirt and they’ll remember the name on the back”. Fans will certainly remember Harry Kane for rightly being a world class striker, but also one loyal to both club and country, without a transfer to a bigger side in pursuit of silverware.
Image: Bluejam via Wikimedia Commons

