Wet shirts and red coats

By Catherine Braddock

The craze surrounding Mr Darcy is unavoidable; from ‘I heart Darcy’ bags to larger-than-life statues, it’s clear some of us are a bit obsessed with this literary figure. It’s easy to blame the lovely Colin Firth and his even lovelier wet shirt for this. We all know (and most of us love) the 1995 TV series. But isn’t it a bit superficial? Darcy is set up as an ideal – the ideal – but given that much of the hype dates from a swimming excursion conceived by screenplay writer Andrew Davies, is Austen writing brilliant men or are people just falling for actors and slightly cheesy set-ups?

It’s not just our generation (or our mothers!) that has fallen for Mr Darcy. Alongside Emma, Pride and Prejudice is the most adapted Austen novel for the big and small screen, even before Colin Firth’s iconic appearance. We could date our affection from first seeing his beautiful grounds at Pemberley but the dialogue between Darcy and Elizabeth is also highly entertaining and achieves levels of eloquence and sass which mere mortals can only aspire to. Their conversations are often combative but they display similar minds in their lively debates and cannot help working together against Miss Bingley. Perhaps – shockingly – we can infer that most people seek a partner they can actually talk to. Or maybe, as novel-readers, we cannot help but be charmed by praise for ‘extensive reading’.

Despite his pride, Darcy demonstrates a capacity to change and acknowledge his mistakes and (after some complications) certainly knows how to declare his love: most ardently. Actors have portrayed Darcy in various ways; Matthew Macfadyen has (however unintentionally) made him something of an icon for social awkwardness through his 2005 performance which allows greater empathy and shows another possible interpretation. As the subject of many discussions, Darcy is an endless source of both supposedly intellectual debate as well as hilarious memes.

What about Austen’s other men? Emma‘s attraction is often the flawed heroine herself but Mr Knightley is an underrated figure for his selfless and considerate nature. Captain Wentworth also appeals for his constancy in love. Henry Tilney, Edward Ferrars and Edmund Bertram are all kind, if somewhat flawed, while the melancholy yet generous Colonel Brandon remains popular for unswerving devotion to Marianne. Austen’s novels weed out the good men from the bad, the Brandons from the Willoughbys, meaning that her heroes convey a sense of virtue or goodness which is certainly engaging. A reader knows that the heroine will find the man who most suitably complements her own virtues.

The men all have attractive qualities but is this really why we read her novels? To rate and gush over her heroes? G. K. Chesterton notes Austen’s ability to “coolly and sensibly describe a man”; something which cannot be said of Andrew Davies! A tendency to over-romanticise is where adaptations often diverge from the novels. It is Austen’s witty narrator and insight into human beings which continues to attract readers. We admire her skill in exploring characters and satirising society, not writing the equivalent of poster pin-ups. So maybe it’s not a question of being Team Darcy or Team Knightley (but this isn’t Twilight, let’s not identify ourselves solely according to a fictional man with a charming smile or a Grecian jawline – we’d rather echo strong Elizabeth, not superficial Lydia), or setting the books and films in total opposition, but enjoying the novels for the skill with which they were written. Austen’s novels are about more than men and interest in them stems more from their minds and a humanity we can relate to, rather than their glorious on-screen presence; Pride and Prejudice, after all, “is only a novel… or, in short, only some work in which the greatest powers of the mind are displayed, in which the most thorough knowledge of human nature, the happiest delineation of its varieties, the liveliest effusions of wit and humour, are conveyed to the world in the best-chosen language”.

Photograph: Pete Birkinshaw