Welsh opt-out system will be a life saver

organ donation

by Frances Gormley

Organ donors save lives. That’s a simple fact. Yet of the 62 million people living in the UK at the moment, only 18.7 million were registered as organ donors in 2012, according to the NHS. If you were to ask the unregistered people what their thoughts on organ donation were, it would be extremely likely that a large proportion of these people would willingly accept a donated organ if necessary and that many probably would actually donate, but just ‘haven’t got round to registering yet’.

Wales have voted to change the current system. Instead of signing up to be an organ donor, everyone will automatically be registered. You can, of course, opt out of this if you don’t want to donate your organs post mortem, but the point is you don’t have to lift a finger to become registered anymore; it will in fact be more hassle to deregister yourself.

Despite the fact that this change could create an alleged 25% increase in registered donors in Wales, leading to many lives being saved, opposition to this bill is still strong. The largest opposition appears to come from religious groups as well as others who believe the state should not involve itself so heavily in such a personal choice. But with one person dying each day in the United Kingdom waiting for a kidney transplants alone, and thousands more waiting for other organs, these opposing arguments appear slightly unjustified.

it is certainly good news for those currently waiting for that life-saving donation.

There are, however, other counter-arguments that state that it should be a country-wide bill rather than localised to Wales. The automatic opt-in will apply to over-18s who die in Wales and have lived there for 12 months or more. Yet the recipient of the organ could be anywhere in the UK, not just Wales.

The opt-out scheme is not a new phenomenon. For example, Belgium has had an opt-out donor scheme since 1986 and in the five years that followed there was a 55% increase in donors, with only 2% of the population choosing to opt-out. This is seen by many advocates of organ donation as an example which should be followed by the UK to increase donations and therefore save lives. Austria, Spain and Chile are just a few others who also employ this way of donating.

Ultimately, the consequences of this bill can only be positive. People are often apathetic with regard to things such as organ donation as many do not view it as an immediate concern to them.  Unfortunately it is often too late before people realise how important organ donors are. The opt-out system would therefore be extremely beneficial for doctors as they will be able to provide more transplants to those who need them without having to wait so long. And as only a minority of people would actively choose not to donate organs, an opt-out system seems to be much more effective than the current structure. Now the scheme has voted in by Wales regulations will have to be agreed before it comes into place in 2015, so its true consequences will not be seen for a few years, but it is certainly good news for those currently waiting for that life-saving donation.