Welfare can’t compensate for examination stress

by James MurrayWork stress 300 x 200

One could easily be mistaken for thinking that university is getting nicer. The library is staying open 24 hours, and even a tent has been erected out front for us to eat – as if the floor of the foyer wasn’t comfortable enough. Then there are the profusion of welfare services on standby for pre-exam breakdowns; counselling, college mentors and senior tutors, Nightline, meditation and, no doubt soon, some kind of soft inflatables will be provided by the StressLess coordinators so we can bounce away that revision angst.

However, in much the same way that charity is the hallmark of a problem society, the extensive welfare available to us is the hallmark of a fairly unpleasant university. The stress associated with our studies is now completely accepted, despite most probably being a substantial contributor to many stress related problems, breakdowns and depressions. Not to mention making learning an unduly odious process.

Instead of trying to calm us down while we are brutally differentiated, welfare should be working to create an educational environment which encourages us to cooperate in contributing to the collective knowledge of humanity.

In Section S3 of the University Health and Safety Manual, stress is defined as “the adverse reaction people have to excessive pressures or other types of demand place upon them. It arises when they worry that they cannot cope”. It suggests that the common causes of stress arise from, amongst others, pressure of work, lack of control over work demands, inflexible and over-demanding work schedules, uncertainty, and poor relations with colleagues.

But while the university remains vigilant for its staff, it is exactly these feelings that are generated by the work we’re set. Rarely do we feel that we have finished an assignment; there are always more citations, reading, editing and proofing that could have been done. After all, who do you know who achieved full marks for an essay?

The university functions according to a celebrated meritocratic process but this is exactly the problem. What we are tested on is not how much do I know about English Literature/Physics but rather how much more English Literature/Physics do I know than the rest of the people in my year? In this way our workload becomes potentially infinite, and as such, an atmosphere is created where work becomes completely pervasive. The meritocratic system is a process of differentiation. We come to university as equals and we leave unequal.

We are driven to constantly feel as though we should be working. Who is satisfied with saying; ‘okay, I’ll spend x amount of time on this assignment and whatever grade I get, that’s fine’?  The increasingly abundant use of the word ‘procrastinate’ highlights this mentality. Having a cup of tea, reading the paper, or contributing to societies, are increasingly referred to as means of procrastinating. Our studies are viewed as completely and totally permeating; any deviation is a delay or frustration to our real work.

This pressure arises because fundamentally the purpose of education has been inverted. Our education is not about leaning a set amount of subject knowledge to later contribute to society but learning more than the rest to later justify taking more than the rest from society. The potential for work will always therefore be infinite, and judged only relative to what others achieve. Under these circumstances we are encouraged to work until breaking point – the point where welfare becomes prerequisite.

It is clear to see that by the university’s own standards the structure of teaching and the environment that has been created is the main cause of stress and the concomitant metal health issues that arise from it. Instead of being united against ignorance in a tradition of solidarity arising from the Enlightenment, knowledge is used as a divisive tool with which to value students and send them off to the job market.

But for society to benefit the most from education this mentality must be addressed. The meritocratic assumption fails to really value individuals, instead it used arbitrary means like punitive timing, formatting and memorising activities to evaluate and attach labels to each of us. The current university welfare system is a bit like stocking better bandages in the first aid box because the building is at risk of collapsing.

Instead of trying to calm us down while we are brutally differentiated welfare should be working to create an educational environment which encourages us to cooperate in contributing to the collective knowledge of humanity, rather than one preoccupied with allocating  entitlement according to a flawed meritocratic assumption.  Do not be fooled, the kindest face of welfare exists to compensate for a much uglier and more brutal side, and it is this visage of compassion that allows the other to dominate our thinking, beliefs and lives.