Welcome to the dark side: Peculius Stage Company’s Dr Faustus

By Donnchadh O’Conaill

The Faust myth is so deeply embedded in our culture that it can thrive in all manner of surprising contexts and guises. But such transplants can hardly match the potency of Marlowe’s poetry, or refract such a range of feelings through the prism of religious and spiritual imagery. This is a play like Durham Cathedral: they don’t build them like this any more, and it’s always worth taking time to rediscover its majesty.

All of which is quite a build-up for Peculius’ production, so it is a pleasure to report that this was an accomplished piece of theatre. David Knowles has made as good a directorial debut as I have seen for a long time. It doesn’t take a great deal of imagination to stage Faust in a venue like the Norman Chapel, but it takes a great deal of attention to detail to make it work. Take something as basic as the seating: the audience sat on three sides, almost all were level with the pillars, at a stroke removing many of the sightline problems that have plagued previous productions here. This also allowed the spaces between the audience and the walls to serve as an off-stage area where the chorus could lurk, handing Faust items as needed, speaking as Legion when Lucifer appears, and heightening our sense of being within Faust’s very chambers.

The directorial skill extended to the lighting, with hand-held torches used to light faces in the darkness and illuminate the ceiling when the characters discussed the heavens. At the very end of the play, the torches produced a simple but spectacular shadow effect on the ceiling. The use of choral music I found less successful. The pieces themselves, some Elizabethan, others written specifically for the production by Ben Rowath, were impressive to these ears at least. However, the music only worked dramatically in the final scene. Otherwise, it was at best superfluous, at worst an irritating distraction.

The seven-strong chorus had almost all the supporting parts, some of which were handled with delightful precision and economy: Joe Burke’s stooped and snarling Lucifer; Dave Spencer’s strutting Pope; Tom McNulty, superbly expressive as Pride and an idiotic cleric. I was less certain about the presentations of some of the seven sins; Wrath was rather obvious, if performed with gusto, whereas Lust could have been made more blatant.

Callum Cheatle gave us Faust as a showman. His delight in astonishing his contemporaries with magical tricks, his satisfaction at having rationalised his choice of the dark arts, his needling Mephistopheles; all spoke of incurable arrogance, and were served up with a flourish and a smirk. Faust, apart from anything else, is too clever by half, and Cheatle was clever enough to convey an intelligence confined by a specifically moral blindness.

Casting Lucy Cornell as Mephistopheles was perhaps not as bold a stroke as it might have appeared, since her gender hardly ever became a theme for either performer. Cornell brought to the part a magnetic stare and a facial tic suggesting a character on the edge of nervous disorder; she found in it Mephistopheles’ deep agony at being cast out of heaven. She knows exactly what awaits Faust in the afterlife, and both pities and despises him for his weakness. When these emotions were properly conveyed, as in the argument with Faust about mentioning God, the exchanges fairly crackled.

Having said that, in general they did not crackle quite enough; which is a way of saying that the show, while very good, fell short of being outstanding. Cornell was excellent when addressing Faust or being addressed, but when not directly involved I thought her presence receded too far. One way to address this might have been the way she walked and stood; there appeared nothing about it to mark her out, certainly nothing to suggest the supernatural. Even more importantly, Faust’s arrogance and brio were not underlain by a sense of vulnerability. The key action in the play occurs between Faust’s first summoning Mephistopheles and his signing the contract. It is absolutely crucial that these scenes are a life-and-death matter to Faust, that he has a definite sense of his terrible error; but in this production these scenes did not reach the intensity needed. He seemed too convinced of his own success to seriously question his decision. To balance self-delusion and self-awareness like this is no mean feat, but it is what the play demands; a protagonist who knows he is throwing away his immortal soul, but who cannot stop himself doing so. It is no mean tribute to the production to say that it came close to capturing this; but it did not quite succeed in signing the contract.