Weighing in on the debate: does silence really speak volumes?
By Charlotte Aspden
I recently listened to the silent album, Is This What We Want?, so you don’t have to.
Two weeks ago, 1,000 UK artists came together to release a surprise album in protest of a proposed UK government bill that would allow AI companies to bypass copyright laws and use available music to train their algorithms unless rights holders choose to opt-out. As part of the MAKE IT F(AI)R campaign, artists are arguing that it would be impossible to opt out of each of the thousands of software companies that are vying for their content.
The 12-track album, comprising mainly of ambient sounds, aims to evoke the creators’ concerned visions of a hollowed-out creative industry where AI threatens the livelihoods of artists. The eerie mix of empty recording studios and silent performance spaces underscores the haunting vision of an industry where human artistry is increasingly threatened and replaced by technology.
The tracks, all uncredited, spell out the campaign´s message: “The British Government must not legalise music theft to benefit AI companies”. Such anonymity enhances this unnerving sense of detachment, with only the sounds of unidentified movements- be it people, machinery, or animals- set against a backdrop of pervasive silence.
“You don’t promote growth in a garden by allowing all the pests to feast on the fruit and flowers, and you don’t promote growth in an economy by allowing all the AIs to feast on the fruits of our creators”
stephen fry
Now whilst this album is technically ambient, its focal sounds are mundane- say a shift of a chair or a deep sigh of frustration from an unknown- and devoid of musicality. The decision to create an album so sonically hollow is a deliberate reflection of the artists’ fear of a world where creative output becomes mechanised and soulless. In ‘British’, for example, the buzz of an indistinguishable noise- whether from bees or machinery- is purposefully left vague. The comment on a conflation between nature and machinery highly potent in its symbolistic value, yet nothing extraordinary.
Even for fans of ambient sound, this album is far from easy listening. Unless you’re desperately seeking any sound to fill your ears, its lack of substance and depth will leave many listeners indifferent. Such apparent undirected sound-production challenges one’s expectations of music for enjoyment as the experience of holding such stillness for the album’s 47-minute run time makes it a deeply unsettling listen.
That said, the album’s primary intent is not commercial appeal, but rather to raise awareness. With all streaming proceeds going to Help Musicians, a charity that supports artists throughout their careers, the album’s lack of commercial appeal is ironic; it seems more like a publicity stunt to spark a conversation about the exploitation of musicians than a genuine effort to raise money and create change. Moreover, the politics of using a major streaming platform like Spotify to launch this fundraising project is highly questionable and hard to ignore. Known for its questionable pay-per-stream model, Spotify seems at odds with the album’s goal of ensuring fair compensation for creators. If artists wish to be compensated for their efforts/time/skills and protect their intellectual property, why publicise the album on a platform that blatantly disregards such qualities?
Irrespective of such issues, the album’s purpose is clear: a bold statement to command the industry to move towards a greater regulation against the unchecked expansion of AI in creative industries. Indeed, the International Confederation of Societies of Authors and Composers published a study in December warning that, unless governments implement robust protections against AI, those in the music industry face a loss of 24% of their revenue by 2028, due to AI’s ability to replicate and distribute their work without compensation.
The reality is, musicality is both a skill and a risky career in today’s economy, where creators’ work can be devalued in the face of advancing technology
The campaign has garnered significant attention, with high-profile names such as, Kate Bush, Annie Lennox, and Paul McCartney reportedly among these anonymous 1000 artists. Yet it is Stephen Fry who has perhaps best encapsulates the campaign’s ethos: “You don’t promote growth in a garden by allowing all the pests to feast on the fruit and flowers, and you don’t promote growth in an economy by allowing all the AIs to feast on the fruits of our creators”.
But there’s a deeper question here: is this campaign truly effective, or simply an out-of-touch stunt? AI can study and replicate the works of musicians, much like how musicians themselves can learn from studying others’ music. But AI doesn’t hear music the way humans do—it cannot feel the emotion, nuance, or intent behind a song. In that sense, is AI’s role in music creation truly as threatening as the rise of impersonators or tribute artists who cover songs note-for-note? Moreover, the concept of a silent album is hardly new. In fact, these 1,000 artists seem to draw inspiration from John Cage’s provocative silent pieces, such as 4’33”, which instructs any combination of musicians to produce no purposeful sounds for the above duration of the piece. His deeply radical conception of ‘silent’ music, simultaneously urged listeners to attune themselves to the sounds around them, suggesting that true silence does not exist. In a similar vein, the ‘Is This What We Want?’ album replicates this desire to focalise one’s attention to the desolate ambient sounds against the backdrop of silence, whilst conveying a heightened political message.
The reality is, musicality is both a skill and a risky career in today’s economy, where creators’ work can be devalued in the face of advancing technology. As AI development continues to evolve, the tension between protecting creative rights and fostering technological progress becomes more pronounced. ‘This Is Music’ reported that music alone contributed £7.6 billion in 2023 to the UK economy in gross value added. On a broader scale, creative industries globally represent trillions in economic activity and millions of jobs. Whilst the UK government argues that their proposed copyright reforms are necessary for competitiveness, many artists- like those behind this album- fear these changes could open the door to the exploitation of musicians’ work without proper compensation. At the heart of this debate is a clash of economic interests.
Who holds the rights to creative content? When is it acceptable to use creative content for AI training? And what compensation models are fair and appropriate?
Whether or not the ‘Is This What We Want’ succeeds in altering the conversation about copyright law and the future of music, it certainly raises these critical questions about the potential consequences of AI’s unchecked growth in the creative industries.
Image Credit: inesjimenez2005 via pixabay

