We Wish You A Merry Christmas Special

David Brent, the king of Christmas special? Photograph: BBC

by Rory Macdowall

In the build-up to Christmas, many things become part of the seasonal fabric – music, decorations and loathsome clichés – but nothing generates excitement quite like waiting for the special of your favourite television comedy. Owing to the lack of Christmas films in cinemas this winter, there is no better time to peruse the very best offerings from television in the past and present.

British comedies have a strong tradition of producing fantastic Christmas specials. The first mention must go to Ricky Gervais and Stephen Merchant, whose The Office and Extras specials are standalone masterpieces among the best television work of the 21st century. Both are funny, bittersweet, satirical, and their portrayals of festivities are sharp reflections of real life. In The Office’s two-part special, filmed as an “X years later” documentary, David Brent has recently lost his position as boss of Slough paper merchant Wernham Hogg. Brent is unable to quite let go of his old life, and he returns to the office Christmas party in the show’s climax. Gervais and Merchant show their almost unparalleled talents for depicting human life as we watch the employees unwind from their unfulfilling jobs. The party soundtrack achieves the perfect blend of nostalgia, emotion, comic tackiness and Christmas spirit. We rejoice as we see things finally fall into place for the characters that luck eluded throughout the series. The Extras special is equally emotional. Andy Millman has finally climbed his way toward the top of the showbiz ladder, but success is not as he imagined it, and he has estranged his friends along the way. Fame becomes like a drug, and Millman agrees to appear on Big Brother – which Gervais and Merchant parody excellently – where he pours his heart out over the regrets he has about the way he has led the past few months of his life. The single episode almost acts as the payoff for the entire series.

Sitcom Only Fools and Horses released a run of Christmas specials, many of which attained viewing figures in excess of 20 million. As a comedy, Only Fools and Horses can be hit-and miss, but the heart which kept the 22 year series beating is something universally relatable. One of the series’ more emotional moments comes in the 1996 Christmas special Modern Men, in which brothers Del Boy and Rodney are trapped in a lift following Rodney’s wife’s miscarriage. It is testament to John Sullivan’s ability as a writer that the line between comedy and tragedy is so frequently and considerately toed. Only Fools and Horses unmistakeably benefits from its family background at Christmas time, conjuring up homely feelings at the right time of the year.

Doctor Who at Christmas – ‘overkill’. Photograph: BBC

While the sitcom formula lends itself particularly well to the Christmas special, often resulting in some of the strongest episodes, recently there has been a multitude of television series cashing in on Christmas in a slightly more tenuous way. Seasonal touches are usually welcome, but it inevitably feels like overkill when Doctor Who specials are being laboriously churned out year after year. You know a Christmas special is half-hearted and contrived when it is considerably worse than the usual show. The Top Gear specials, such as the ones in India and the USA, have been great spectacles with some fantastic photography, but the gags have been overly staged, shedding the candid charm of the early series. Nevertheless, the upcoming Top Gear special, which may be airing as late as 2013, will be a highlight of the Christmas television season.

As with Only Fools and Horses, whose string of specials outlived the original series by twelve years, it is not uncommon for shows to be kept running by their Christmas specials. Top of the Pops, one of the very first programs to feature a Christmas special back in 1964, was axed in 2006 but is reincarnated every December 25th as a tribute to the importance of the show in its heyday.