We Pretty Pieces of Flesh by Colwill Brown: Dylan Thomas Prize review

By Megan Campbell

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Rach, Shaz and Kel, our “Donny lasses”, open Colwill Brown’s debut novel We Pretty Pieces of Flesh. Shortlisted for the Dylan Thomas Prize, Brown’s first stride from short stories to longer fiction embodies the trials and tribulations of a girlhood emerging into fragile adulthood. Brown offers a distinctive narrative style by switching between first and third person narratives in a unique Southern Yorkshire “Donny” (Doncaster) dialect. Among “pot dealers and pedos”, the women find their identities through the prism of their friendship and individually as the tides of privilege, politics and one serious sexual assault threaten to tear them apart. Though unapologetically and profoundly Northern, Rach, Shaz and Kel offer universal truths of friendship and girlhood. From the politics of the playground, to the disagreements of adolescence (hazy with the “E” Shaz supplies the girls on their venture into Sheffield). Even by their thirties, the girls are still embattled by the same fundamental truths which challenged their younger selves. 

Rach, “Rachel Gifford, BA PGCSE”, appears first in the narrative, reminiscing on days in “Donny”, and alludes to her status as “better off” as she hides a ten-pound note in her bra from her mum and dad at home for a night out in Sheffield. This immediately sets the tone, with class and family established as a dividing factor among the girls: Shaz and Kel come from working class backgrounds and single parent families, sharing the vocabulary of “mam” and “fatha”. Jealousy divides the girls within their strong bond from the off: Rach and Kel’s initial friendship from primary school is threatened by the arrival of Shaz with her “scrunchies bigger than any girls scrunchies”. Later, the quality of their “stripper heels” internally divides Rachel as she names them “classier” than the rest. Concern with appearance and body image echoes through the text, alongside the issue of class politics which is implicit in their words. 

The girls are still embattled by the same fundamental truths which challenged their younger selves

While Brown comes alive through her depiction of class prejudice, her true mastery lies in the discussion of men and sexual desire. Almost claustrophobic, laser-focussed on “Donny”, the women appear trapped within the male gaze which oversees their tale. Sexual harassment and assault is commonplace, with Kel’s experience with Ando, a boy two years her senior, at “Nappy Night” at the “Donny Dome” in Year 7 where she is groped, and again when she later lay atop nettles as love is made to her behind a local fish and chip shop. These nettles sting as pleasure is forced onto her yet are part of Brown’s interlinking of pain and pleasure, with Doncaster’s signature phrase “Bang you” revealing a violent misogyny baked into the culture of “Donny”. Cultural misogyny is similarly discussed, with the girls’ competition, not just for the advent of womanhood (“We yelped, we moaned, pined for paracetamol, cried out for feminax.”), but for sexual validation amongst themselves as they tiptoe the line to become a culturally acceptable “alreyt lasses”, neither “frigid” nor “slaggy shit stirrers”.

As a student at Durham University often passing through “Donny” on the LNER, I have heard “Donny as a punch line of a joke” or as a place to change “trains once ont way to London”. This novel speaks to its strong regional identity within the North that initially felt physically apart from my personal experience further south. Durham University by no means underrepresents the “posh cunts down south” that Rach takes aim at in the opening pages. But though I was far from the “Donny Dome” in the early noughties, Brown immediately welcomed me as her reader, and I was soon enchanted by the universal chord she strikes. “Donny’s” boasting of its “highest boozer to human ratio” is shared by “every lost borough in England”. While Shaz’s mourning of a time when “You thinking It was safer to be a girl” creates an intimate and more sinister tone that is no less universal. 

Offering a heady cocktail of sexual harassment and violence, body image, substance abuse, class struggle, and political turmoil in local communities

Offering a heady cocktail of sexual harassment and violence, body image, substance abuse, class struggle, and political turmoil in local communities (Rach allegedly voted for Brexit). Rach, Shaz and Kel’s friendship is a microcosm of girlhood and, perhaps, more as the three re-enact Romeo and Juliet (with Mercutio alongside) during their school days with the positions anonymised in the third person perspective of the chapter. Brown’s girls are strong, unyielding and determined not be defeated in a quest for their own identities. Their spirits will not be broken. Brown invites us to do the same.

Image: Chato and Windus via Amazon.