We must stop the petty BBC witch hunt

by Madeline Ratcliffe

It didn’t last long did it? The golden summer of the London Olympics, when the BBC was lauded by all for its fantastic coverage, and no one had anytime for The Daily Mail’s mean-spirited trouble-stirring.

In the last few weeks, the BBC has been widely criticised for not calling Savile’s behaviour into question earlier, with Labour’s deputy leader Harriet Harman saying the claims about Savile “cast a stain” on the corporation, and Culture Secretary Maria Miller declaring she had “very real concerns” about public trust in the BBC.

There is a familiar pattern to these statements. MPs and various media organizations fall over themselves to condemn our national broadcaster at any opportunity. They ask the same questions about the worth and integrity of the BBC each time, using the license fee as a universal validation for every attack on the corporation, all in the name public interest and benefit. But, it seems to be far less about answerability, than getting their own back on the institution that holds them to account most of the time.

This is not to suggest of course that we shouldn’t expect the BBC to be fully accountable, or that if there are those who are guilty of covering up Savile’s wrongdoing, that they shouldn’t be punished. But, it is quite a jump from rightly denouncing those individuals – if any – who took part in a cover-up, to blaming the entire, vast organization.

The BBC should take these allegations extremely seriously and deal with them appropriately, and so far they have been doing this with multiple independent and internal inquiries commissioned, and the Panorama investigation into the Newsnight editors.

The Daily Mail asked: “Can it REALLY be that no one inside the smug BBC knew?” However, what we must remember, is that there is quite a difference between hearing the common rumours about Savile’s reputation that may have been flying around the BBC, and knowing for certain that they were true and having the proof to act, but failing to.

Being aware of the rumours is not the same as taking part in a cover-up, and to act on hearsay without evidence is a very dangerous path to go down; it’s foolish to judge in retrospect.

We should defend our national broadcaster more fiercely than ever

Indeed, back in 2007 Surrey police did question Savile over the allegations of child sex abuse and the matter was referred to the Crown Prosecution Service, which advised there was insufficient evidence to take further action.

In 2008, Sussex police received a complaint of sexual assault against Savile, which allegedly took place in 1970, but they were later forced to drop the investigation because they said the victim was “unwilling to co-operate in any investigation”. This was the reason Peter Rippon, the ex-editor of Newsnight, gave for dropping the investigation into the abuse allegations against Savile in December 2011, ten months before the ITV report brought them to the public’s attention.

The Mail also argues that because we pay for it, we own it, but this does not justify an indiscriminate branding of the BBC as “criminal”. In this latest scandal, The Mail appears to hold the BBC responsible not only for the failure to prosecute Savile, but apparently for the collective failure to realise what was going on. Savile had great national popularity and the newspaper lambastes the BBC for not reflecting the country’s value system, but instead creating a “dismal celebrity culture” (which of course The Mail has had no hand in).

It would make as much sense for them to blame every Briton who enjoyed Savile’s programmes for enabling him. The Daily Mail likes to paint itself as the protector of British values and the public’s ‘honour’, but I know which institution I’d prefer to be the safeguard of our national morality and media standards…

There is nothing to suggest that the entire organisation was involved

Jonathan Dimbleby, in an interview with The Times lamented the “disturbing relish in the way the critics have laid into the BBC”, calling it a “witch-hunt” against the corporation. He said this had become “horribly out of proportion”, and warned against holding people in office today accountable for what happened thirty years ago, especially as “no-one thought about [paedophilia] 50 years ago” in the same way as they do now. Dimbleby added that it was “very distressing” that people at the BBC were being “hounded” in a way that was “unwarranted” before there was proof of any misdemeanor.

If it transpires that there was a cover-up by certain BBC employers, then they absolutely should be brought to justice, but the (alleged) corruption of a few branches is not reason enough to fell a whole tree. There is nothing to suggest that the entire organisation was involved in protecting and enabling Savile and a few rogue individuals should not be allowed to tarnish the reputation of arguably the world’s finest media organisation.

Now, in the light of the hacking scandal and the issues of press ethical standards raised by the Leveson Inquiry – which has prompted questions about the suitability of the Sky Corporation’s influence – we should defend our national broadcaster more fiercely than ever.