We must cut through partisan welfare rhetoric to find truth

IDS

by Brendan Atess

Iain Duncan Smith, the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, claimed this week that he could survive on £53 a week – the amount some benefit claimants are suspected to live on, which has sparked a media backlash from opponents of the coalition’s welfare reforms.

Speaking on Radio 4’s Today Programme on Monday, IDS claimed “If I had to I would.” This was in response to the story of David Bennett, 51, a market trader from Hunwick, County Durham. Bennett was earlier asked by the show’s presenter, John Humphrys, whether there was anything he would like to ask IDS, to which he sneeringly replied “Could you survive on £53 a week?”

Since then, a petition set up on change.org calling for IDS to go ahead and prove his claim by living on the meagre weekly budget for at least one year, has gathered over 150,000 online signatures. Political journalist George Monbiot claimed responsibility for the petition idea, arguing in today’s Guardian newspaper that it was “a stunt to shame the oblivious aristocrats”. IDS has already come out and defended his welfare reforms, stating that they are “fair to taxpayers”.

Initial media responses to this story have been predictable across the political spectrum.

Easy points were scored by several bloggers and political editors from The Guardian, The Independent and New Statesman, who wrote yet more articles criticising the government’s inhumane assault on the poor and insisting that IDS and his cabinet colleagues try life on the minimum wage or less for themselves. Bennett, for them, was just another opportunity to sing the same old tune – not a time for serious fact-checking.

By contrast, journalists at The Telegraph and Daily Mail seemed to be more concerned to reassure Middle Englanders and Britain’s working-class conservatives that they needn’t be too guilt-ridden about the plight of their compatriots. According to their sources, Bennett was, after all, nothing more than a divorced liar who once gambled the money he inherited from his Grandmother. All of which may turn out to be true. But what about the thousands of other benefit claimants who we suspect of being pushed into poverty undeservingly by the government’s reforms? What is there to learn from this story?

Cutting through the moral indignation on both sides one could easily wonder how any of this amounts to proper scrutiny of government policy.

Well if you had already decided that you were not the government’s biggest fan then the past few days has been yet another excuse to ignore the policy details and jump straight to the part where you shout “See! I knew the Coalition was a bunch of evil bastards!” (Indeed, this author would certainly fall into this category most weeks).

On the other hand, if you had long since decided that everyone who claims things like housing benefit is a no-good scrounger then your theory has also remained unbroken thanks to the noble work of the dirt-diggers at your news outlet of choice.

Cutting through the moral indignation on both sides one could easily wonder how any of this amounts to proper scrutiny of government policy. The fact is this is what news is for most of us, most of the time – a chance not to be ‘informed’ but to have our biases confirmed.

For interest, there are currently 2.5 million people unemployed and looking for work in the UK according to the Office for National Statistics. And figures show that nearly a million of those are people aged 16-24.  Jobseeker’s allowance for this age group is £56.25. Even when taking into account other benefits such as crisis loans and housing and heating benefits, the increasing real cost of essential items mean life on the breadline is far from pretty. And even if you’re lucky enough to be employed, there’s every chance your life isn’t much better as the National Minimum Wage is now worth less in real terms than it was back in 2004.

From the left there should not currently be any need to make every moving story appear as evidence that the Coalition is an immoral pack of public school pleb-bashers. The cold facts about the following three issues alone will serve just as well to win the debate six-days-out-of-seven: the tanking British economy, the empirically-observed social consequences of austerity and the absurd amount over-privileged elites in Westminster.

And from the right, if you actually believe the government’s policies are on the whole economically and ethically sound, then maybe your best pundits should spend more of their time proving it with reason and evidence. You just have the following to convince the rest of us about: the ‘wisdom’ of the austerity strategy. There’s no need to paint everyone you don’t like as a feckless deviant.

Of course, there are those journalists who do try to present the facts and only draw conclusions which seem to have the weight of evidence behind them – a fairly long list in fact. However, we all know that, usually, neither you nor I get half as much satisfaction from reading balanced arguments when there’s a full-blown rant to be had. Therein lies the problem.

But just so you know, the government is evil.

Photograph: US Department of Labor