We must change our neo-colonial views

Newspapers 300x200

by David Hynes

As cities around the world welcomed in the New Year with dazzling fireworks shows, there was one place where the pyrotechnics were conspicuous by their absence. In light of recent events, the annual display in New Delhi had been cancelled. Whilst the world partied, the Indians protested.

Similar to the response to the mass shooting in Sandy Hook, the brutal gang-rape, and subsequent death, of the 23 year old student in the Indian capital has provoked a period of soul-searching. For weeks after the event, the city experienced protests – occasionally violent – expressing the nation’s outrage. The situation was exacerbated by news that a similar rape had taken place earlier this month in the Gurdaspur district of the Punjab. Clearly India has questions to answer about the place of women in society.

Luckily for the Indians, the British commentariat were on hand to help diagnose the problem. Leading the charge was Libby Purves, who wrote in The Times that in India, “murderous, hyena-like male contempt is a norm”. It is, after all, a society where “sexual harassment and assault” are considered a ‘male birthright’. Ever keen to contribute, the Daily Mail promised that it would reveal the extent of “India’s rape crisis”.

A society which condones casual misogyny is one hardly fit to pass judgement on another’s treatment of women.

Coming from a paper whose most popular online section exists to document female celebrities in various states of undress, the pro-feminine stance contained a certain amount of irony. The Mail is just one player in the British media which strives to present women in sexualised context, the most obvious example being The Sun’s Page Three. The insidious consequences of this occasionally manifest themselves in more extreme terms. In a barely concealed rape reference, the December edition of FHM advised men that “it’s never acceptable to wear your girlfriend/mother/victim’s socks”.

Before launching into scathing indictments of Indian society, the British media might do well to consider some of the rape numbers closer to home. A recent report from the Office for National Statistics revealed that one fifth of British women experience sexual assault during their lifetime.

There are around 75,000 cases of rape each year and only 1070 of those which are reported end in convictions. Surely a 1.4% conviction rate is indicative of a ‘rape crisis’?

Nor are we as students removed from these national statistics. A recent NUS survey showed that 7% of women suffered serious sexual assault as a student, and a worrying 68% said they had experienced some kind of sexual harassment.

These numbers, and especially the growing trend of blaming victims of rape, are a damning reflection on a society in which the sexualisation of women has become accepted. Encouraged by websites such as UniLad, parts of university culture have seemingly embraced this new cultural norm.

Take for example socials. Themes such as ‘pimps and hoes’ are common across universities in the UK; during my time at Durham I have seen a number of socials whose theme appeared to be little more than requiring the female attendees to wear as few clothes as possible.

In a moving piece in the last edition of the Palatinate, a Durham student called for men to think carefully about flippant remarks on sexual crimes. She correctly wrote that “jokes or comments demeaning women, no matter how harmless the intent, give credence to the idea that women are second-class citizens”.

A society which condones casual misogyny is one hardly fit to pass judgement on another’s treatment of women.

Over the coming months, Indian society will hopefully look within itself for the answers to its problems with rape. In the meantime, the British media should drop its neo-Victorian attitude towards events in India. The days of imposing moral standards on the Empire are over; we should instead be supporting Indian women in their fight for a more female-friendly society.

In the future, maybe Libby Purves can dedicate more column inches to our own rape issues. After all, true change begins at home.