Laws against bad history?

Australian citizen Dr Gerald Toben was remanded in custody this month following his arrest at Heathrow airport by British police from Scotland Yard’s extradition unit. He was on a flight from America en route to Dubai, but upon touching down on British soil Dr Toben’s plane was boarded by British police and he was arrested under a European arrest warrant at the request of German authorities.
Dr Toben is a holocaust denier and he is alleged to have published online material “of an anti-semitic and/or revisionist nature”. This is a crime in Germany and in accordance with agreements signed in 2003 by the UK with other EU members, Dr Toben will be extradited to Germany, facing up to five years in prison if convicted.

I should state from the outset that I share most people’s idea of what the holocaust was – an attempt to exterminate the Jewish population in Europe – and I think that there is more than adequate evidence to justify believing that this is what happened. But these facts only serve to show Dr Toben’s views are senseless and offensive, not criminal. I don’t see any problem with describing him as an awful man who has been unfairly imprisoned.

Yet it seems a de facto law against holocaust denial has slipped into British law. What’s worse, this issue as far as I’m aware has not been debated by our own parliament – or at least it hasn’t been debated any more than the European arrest warrants have been. Given that the number of issued arrest warrants is increasing year on year (they doubled to around 6,900 in 2005 from the previous year), I think a fresh parliamentary debate on the extradition procedure should be had. I very much doubt that the MPs who voted for the bill did so with the intention of writing thought crime into UK law.

With the attached risk of being taken as if I were Eurosceptic I should state my belief that this issue is quite separate from whether you are pro-European or very much opposed to the integration project. There is no reason why the UK should surrender its citizens (or in this case foreign ones) to the behest of any other authority – European or not – which has laws not in our own statute. It strikes me as odd that the government is complying with extradition laws which so clearly undermine the justice system of this country.

The original purpose of the legislation was to fast-track extradition procedures, removing the political dimension which had formerly allowed politicians to have the final say on whether any given extradition would go forward. This new simpler procedure was supposed to make it easier to convict the terrorists and real crooks, instead of facilitating German and Austrian authorities in pursuing perceived thought crime.

Though wading into the technicalities of European law it seems Dr Toben’s extradition could be blocked. The Extradition Act 2003 lists thirty-two offences for which the principle of criminal duality – the very sensible principle that the alleged crime must be a crime in the country the accused is being extradited from (as well as the country pressing for extradition) – has been abolished. However, holocaust denial is not on the list of the thirty-two offences for which the UK would not have a say; the UK has a clear case which it could make to block the extradition if it wanted to.

In fact there have been similar cases where EU member states have not complied with the new extradition law; as cited by Chris Huhne, Belgium is refusing to extradite its citizens to Poland for murder charges relating to abortion, a precedent which the UK could follow.

Still, the government seems reluctant to intervene in the case of Dr Toben – for fear of appearing to support a holocaust denier no doubt. As ever the inappropriate use of power is readily disregarded when there is a chance that the onlooker may be harmed in the process, especially when a reputation could be besmirched. Why after all should the government care to protect the rights of a holocaust denier when there is the associated risk of having a few small minded people confuse justice with endorsement?

Freedom of expression is a right in this country, we do not ban ideas or imprison those who we disagree with, no matter how strongly. This is at least a doctrine of true liberalism; current thought within European liberal democracies seems to be edging towards banning what are perceived to be the wrong ideas.

As a case in point, there are many critics of Turkey’s bid to join the EU who ground their objections on Turkey’s refusal to accept responsibility for the massacre of around 1.5 million Armenians in 1915-6 as an act of genocide. A few years ago, a planned conference at Bosphorus University for historians to debate the aforementioned events was cancelled mainly due to government pressure (the then Turkish justice minister Cemil Cecik described the historians as “preparing to stab Turkey in the back”).

Turkey, according to a significant number of liberals, should not join the EU while it effectively bans the idea that an Armenian genocide happened; however, Germany and Austria can be in the EU without having to remove their bans on holocaust denial. So banning ideas is supposed to be fine in principle as long as they are the ideas we disagree with? The liberals have presented the world with a version of history which must be adhered to or else.

The truly liberal state gives freedom to express ideas whatever shape they take. Anyone who strongly disagrees with holocaust deniers up to the point of feeling that these people should be imprisoned would be better off not granting the ideas of Gerald Toben et al an intellectual status by claiming they need to be taken seriously: the truth will speak for itself. Surely the history of the twentieth century has shown that a state which attempts to ban certain ideas invariably leads us down the wrong path.