Was it right to call Tony Abbott a sexist?
With almost two million YouTube views in the last week, Australia’s first female Prime Minister Julia Gillard’s fiery attack on Leader of the Opposition Tony Abbott has gone viral.
Gillard berated Abbott for over fifteen minutes in the House of Representatives stating: ‘I will not be lectured about sexism and misogyny by this man… if he wants to know what misogyny looks like in modern Australia … he needs a mirror’.
Such prejudice, she argued, was evident in his decision to give speeches next to signs describing Gillard as a male politician’s ‘bitch’, before later telling the press ‘I’ve had enough. Australian women have had enough. When I see sexism and misogyny I’m going to call them for what they are.’
Gillard’s courage in openly condemning the problem of sexism towards women in public life justifiably received a great deal of sympathy. Australian news site ‘New Matilda’ described Gillard’s speech as a sign of ‘a re-emergence of feminism in public life’. In fact, the debate has been so high-profile that the editor of ‘Macquarie’, Australia’s equivalent to the OED, intends to amend the long-standing definition of ‘misogyny’ (the ‘hatred of women’) to include ‘entrenched prejudice against women’, to reflect the modern usage and understanding of the term.
Unfortunately though, much of the coverage of the Gillard debate has missed the point. Certainly Gillard was right to expose Abbott’s previously reactionary attitude to women, which included an appeal to ‘what the housewives of Australia need to understand as they do the ironing’ in energy policy discussions, and reference to abortion as ‘the easy way out’.
There is no doubt that women remain under-represented and under-valued in what continues to be a male-dominated world. In Gillard’s own profession only 27% of MPs are women, while the difference between men and women’s full-time pay is a significant 17%.
However, media coverage has totally disregarded the context of the Gillard-Abbott debate: the House was debating a motion calling for the resignation of the Speaker of the Lower House, Peter Slipper, after a series of text messages were released revealing his vulgar and derogatory references to female genitalia in exchanges with a former staffer.
You might be thinking that Gillard’s passionate speech against the sort of sexism in public life that Slipper’s attitude clearly demonstrated was in proposition of the motion. In actual fact, Gillard gave him her full support and opposed the motion calling for his resignation.
In supporting Slipper despite his repulsive comments objectifying women, Deputy Leader of the Opposition Julie Bishop’s comment that Gillard would ‘be remembered as the Prime Minister who let down the women of Australia when put to the test’ is clearly justified. In fact, despite Gillard’s attack on Abbott’s sexist attitudes, in not pushing for Slipper’s resignation Gillard seems to legitimise such opinions in high politics.
However, perhaps the most reprehensible aspect of this debate, has been the less than thoughtful use of such terms as ‘misogyny’ without a proper understanding of their definition. Gillard was right to speak out against the sexism she has faced. In Australia, sexism in public life seems particularly prevalent, demonstrated by Liberal Senator Bill Heffernan’s statement that the ‘deliberately barren’ and unmarried Gillard was not fit to lead the country. However, there is a distinction between the existence of sexism in society and calling an individual a sexist.
Simply put, the Speaker’s standards were unavoidably those of the Prime Minister unless she took an active stand against such opinions. It is clear then that Gillard is herself as much responsible of hypocrisy as Abbott by tolerating such views in politics when politically expedient: Gillard currently heads a minority coalition government.
Furthermore, by using the specific term ‘misogynist’, i.e. ‘one who hates women’, Gillard and other contemporary feminists perpetuate the idea that sexual inequality is an ‘us’ and ‘them’ problem, with women the victims and men the perpetrators.
Gillard’s own culpability in the embedding of sexist attitudes in public life should be evidence enough that women have a significant role to play in refusing to tolerate sexist attitudes. And if sexual equality can ever be achieved it can only be done through the realisation that men have to be part of the solution – an idea that the accusation of ‘misogyny’ cannot accommodate.
The final word should go to the Australian Greens’ Deputy Leader Adam Bandt who stated ‘I think yesterday decency was being trashed all around by everyone frankly’. The crude obsession both Gillard and Abbott demonstrated with party-political gains perhaps best demonstrates that deep thinking about the pervasiveness of sexism in society hardly ever takes place in high politics.
If we ever want to see men and women on equal terms we will need to go beyond the simplistic presentations and shallow arguments presented by those who claim higher authority.
Photograph: Flickr
Illustration: Christian Kriticos

