Waiting for Sue Gray

By Adam Bakewell

As the number of parties held at 10 Downing Street during the pandemic seemed to grow exponentially with new leaks such as ‘wine-time Fridays’ exposed regularly, the line we were repeatedly force fed from the Prime Minister and his cabinet is to “please wait for Sue Gray.” But who is the mysterious Sue Gray and why has she been chosen to lead the inquiry into the Number 10 party scandal? 

Gray was not the first civil servant to be appointed by Prime Minister Boris Johnson to investigate lockdown-breaking parties in his home, with Cabinet Secretary Simon Case initially appointed. Case had to embarrassingly recuse himself on 18th December after reports of a party held in his private office, thus leading to the appointment of Sue Gray. She is the first Second Permanent Secretary in the Cabinet Office since 2016 and was expected to take the role of head of the Northern Irish Civil Service in 2018, however cross-community failure to agree on a candidate led to a return to her current position in Whitehall in April 2021.

Gray has had an impressive career in the civil service spanning over 40 years

Gray has had an impressive career in the civil service spanning over 40 years, with 20 of those years in the Cabinet Office in Whitehall. She is non-partisan having worked with both Labour and Conservative governments, however the fact that she works for the current government has led to questions over her impartiality.

She has been praised by former Prime Minister Gordon Brown in his memoirs for always giving “wise advice… when crises befell.” In the coalition years, minister Oliver Letwin stated that “she effectively runs our great United Kingdom.” There is no doubt in Gray’s credentials but conducting an investigation into a Prime Minister she ultimately works for is no doubt uncomfortable. There is a need for the report to fill the large appetite of raging public opinion, otherwise Gray and the civil service will face parallel anger to that faced by the PM.

Gray has experience in investigating senior ministers: in 2017 her report into Damian Green during Theresa May’s premiership forced the minister to step down after he made misleading statements about claims that pornography was found on his work computer. However, the Green investigation was requested by the then-Prime Minister about a senior minister; now we have an investigation requested by the Prime Minister about himself and his officials.

Gray has not shied away from producing damning reports of senior public officials in the past

It is certainly unusual for a senior Whitehall civil servant to investigate the leader of the country and even more unusual for a (prime) Minister to request an inquiry about themselves. Gray has not shied away from producing damning reports of senior public officials in the past and has described herself as “a disrupter and a challenger.”  We are yet to see whether this will extend to the Prime Minister and are unlikely to see the full report until after the conclusion of the police investigation into the matter.

It is not Sue Gray’s place to judge behaviour or whether the Prime Minister misled Parliament but to provide an objective report of events. Whatever the full findings of Sue Gray’s report, this is a scandal even Boris Johnson will struggle to wriggle out of. The inquiry highlights the need for a system of standards in the UK Government in which independent professionals can investigate injustices at the highest of levels. We cannot expect a civil servant who serves the Government of the day to be completely impartial, even if they come with the respect earned by the author of this investigation.

Image: gov.uk via Wikimedia Commons

Support Palatinate