Violence in theatre: not a modern phenomenon

Greg Plummer as The Soldier and Henry Fell as Ian in Bailey Theatre Company's recent production of 'Blasted'. The production received very mixed reviews about its controversial content.
Greg Plummer as The Soldier and Henry Fell as Ian in Bailey Theatre Company’s recent production of ‘Blasted’. The production received very mixed reviews about its controversial content.

Felix Hawlin discusses why violence may still be shocking but is not unique to modern drama, following Bailey Theatre Company’s controversial production of ‘Blasted’. 

When it first was staged in 1995 Sarah Kane’s Blasted was met with critical incomprehension. From the predictable Daily Mail (Headline: ‘A Disgusting Feast of Filth’), to even The Independent (like ‘having your whole head held down in a bucket of offal’), it was hard to find any mainstream outlet that saw beyond the play’s shockingly graphic violence. Most reviews consisted of not much more than a list of the various horrendous acts committed onstage. Even now, they are worth repeating for the uninitiated. Featuring two rapes, a man having his eyeballs sucked out and eaten, and the cannibalising of a baby, the play has certainly not lost its shock value.

The reason to bring all this up is that, twenty years after it was first staged, Blasted has been put on by Bailey Theatre Company. Even after all this time, the way in which most audiences react seems unchanged. Many comment solely on the violent content, as if this was all the play had to offer. Yet since it was originally performed critical appreciation of Blasted has moved far beyond simple shock at its violence.

Set initially in an ordinary Leeds hotel room, the set is quite literally blasted apart as it is revealed the play exists within a war zone, the acts of horror within it bring the cruelty of conflict directly to an ordinary British landscape. The contents of the play are no more than a reflection of reality, at the time a comment on the evil in the Bosnian war.

In 2015 the play’s representations are more relevant than ever. With the campaign of rape, torture, and starvation currently taking place in Syria and Iraq, it would seem we cannot afford to emotionally distance ourselves from the realities of the world we inhabit. Depictions of violence are seemingly essential, as Kane herself puts it “If you are saying you can’t represent something, you are saying you can’t talk about it, you are denying its existence.”

It is clearly not the physical content of theatre which has changed, rather the reaction which audiences have to it

However, there remains the ever present danger that violence in scripts will be used simply as another tactic to entertain. This is the trap which the production might arguably have fallen into. In this case it becomes nothing more than a horror show; with the text itself so flawed, the shock is used simply as a crutch to prove the controversial standing of the production.

Andrew Shires for Durham Student Theatre’s First Night described how the audience became “desensitised” to the events onstage, with many elements less shocking but instead “coming across as ludicrous”. Kane was aware of this potential hazard. In the first German production she condemned that “it completely glamorised the violence. The director thought it was a stage version of Tarantino. It’s not”. Although Kane clearly wished to transcend this style, it would seem to most people her script never even begins to conveys such noble intentions.

Audiences have never found it too difficult to accept the idea of non-gratuitous violence. As modern plays, works like Blasted have to try harder than others to justify themselves. But to look back, even in Shakespeare there are equally shocking events. In Titus Andronicus Lavinia is raped before having her tongue and hands cut off, while Tamora is tricked into eating her two sons who have been baked into a pie. In King Lear a man has his eyes plucked out, while the body count of Hamlet or Macbeth goes beyond anything near what is seen in Blasted.

Even the racist and misogynist spouting of Kane’s characters is arguably met by those in The Merchant of Venice or The Taming of the Shrew. Yet when these plays receive attention it is hardly ever for their violence, but for their beauty; they are not ‘filth’, so why is Blasted?

It is clearly not the physical content of theatre which has changed, rather the reaction which audiences have to it. It is arguably only Kane’s premature death which allowed her plays to be so quickly revaluated and accepted for what they are. But it remains hard to take the savagery of works like Blasted at face value.

This failure to take onstage violence seriously is a reflection of how it is experienced in the everyday. Usually encountered in such trivial ways, when confronted with the seriousness of Kane’s violence, the natural instinct is often revulsion. But as Kane points out “we need those moral ordeals”. If we are shocked, we need to be shocked. Particularly as Durham students experience this play, they should be reminded that it is hardly unique, but nevertheless deserves more thoughtful attention than many will give it.

Photograph: Angana Narula