Vincegate: the latest hidden microphone scandal should be a final warning to politicians
In this month of New Year’s resolutions, politicians should plan to avoid making the kind of blunder that caused some of the biggest media storms of the last 12 months.
Vince Cable, the Secretary of State for Business, Skills and Innovation, was recorded as saying he could bring down the coalition and had waged war on the media magnate, Rupert Murdoch.
Undercover reporters from the Daily Telegraph posed as Liberal Democrat supporters as they secretly recorded the cabinet minister’s comments, revealed by the paper in just before Christmas.
The immediate repercussions were hugely damaging. In claiming that being in the coalition was “like fighting a war”, and that he could bring it down if he desired, Mr Cable made a mockery of the sensible, new politics that we were told to expect by David Cameron and Nick Clegg after last year’s general election.
Worse, as Business Secretary, Mr Cable was adjudicating in the potential takeover of BskyB by Mr Murdoch’s company, News Corporation, and the senior Liberal Democrat’s comments brought his impartial role into disrepute. David Cameron, placed in an awkward and embarrassing situation, severely reduced Mr Cable’s brief.
The incident was another serious dent to the public’s trust in politicians’ credibility, exposing a gap between the public and private spheres. It was also a reminder of “Bigotgate” – the colourful moment during the election campaign when Gordon Brown, accidentally leaving his microphone on, called a female member of the public “bigoted”, after having a civil conversation with her. This blunder, brought about by a technological slip and a rude comment, was one of the final nails in the coffin for the Labour government.
More recently, Conservative peer Lord Young was forced to resign from his advisory role in November after telling another Daily Telegraph journalist over lunch that most people had “never had it so good”, despite the tough economic climate. Lord Young was not being secretly recorded, but his inappropriate comments should never have been publicly voiced, especially to a broadsheet editor. It made the public question whether the Conservative-led coalition was wildly out of touch with public opinion.
After the range of examples in 2010, politicians clearly should be more tactful and reserved with any comments that they make in the media age.
However, that’s not to say that private conversations and opinions should be stifled. Discussions have to go on behind closed doors. Without proper debate, free speech and a wide range of beliefs amongst our elected representatives, democracy and fair government would cease to function.
But, there needs to be self-regulation.
Firstly, politicians should be aware that microphones could be anywhere nowadays in this news-driven era of Wikileaks and 24-hour live coverage. A private conversation with a constituent, as in the case of Vince Cable, might not be such an opportunity to speak freely.
Whether it’s from a secret microphone or one that’s been accidently left on, damning audio evidence can be a public relations disaster in our multimedia world. Even outside of politics, the scandal surrounding match-fixing allegations against snooker player John Higgins stemmed from a hidden recording of the illicit negotiations.
Secondly, although surreptitious recordings are not a particularly honest means of gathering information, it is a matter of dignity and professionalism that powerful public figures should not be making overly controversial comments. Even if we did not have the audio evidence, the general public would not like to believe that, for example, Vince Cable was planning to block a business takeover for political reasons, abusing his cabinet position.
The numerous microphone blunders and inappropriate comments of the last year should come to an end. Politicians and public figures can never be sure who is listening anymore, so there is even more reason for them to speak with good judgement and awareness of public perception. Therefore, as we look forward to a 2011 full of renewed promise, hopefully politicians can resolve to change too.
