VC accepts another increase

Chris Higgins_cut

By Amal Vaidya

Correction: the print edition that featured this article erroneously reported the Vice-Chancellor’s ‘salary’ when it should have referred to his ‘overall package’.

Data gathered by Times Higher Education has shown that vice chancellors of leading universities received significant increases in benefits and pay over the past year.

The revelation has provoked criticism from both student groups and teaching unions, especially in light of the recent tuition fee increase and the strike action taken by academics last month.

The information shows that during 2013, vice-chancellors of Russell Group universities received an average 5.2 percent increase in overall benefits.

Durham’s Professor Christopher Higgins received an increase of £14,000, raising his package to £283,000. His counterparts in institutions like the Universities of Cambridge and Birmingham received even larger increases.

Michael MacNeil, head of higher education at the University and College Union has called the increase in vice-chancellor benefits a “startling hypocrisy.” He said:

“Many vice-chancellors have talked down to their staff and told them to accept a one per cent rise as it is the best they can expect, while happily pocketing big sums themselves.”

However, not all university leaders have accepted an increase. Simon Gaskell, principal of Queen Mary University, has donated his ÂŁ50,000 rise to a scholarship fund, while City University vice-chancellor has rejected a ÂŁ42,000 bonus.

Professor Gaskell has said that he found it “inappropriate” to accept the rise, whilst adding that the decision was a “completely personal choice” and that he did not intend to make a judgement about vice-chancellors who chose to accept pay hikes.

Neither leader has accepted a pay hike in the last three years.

Universities have claimed that the pay rises are tied to the individual’s performance. Robert Gillespie, chairman of Durham University Council, said that “competitive salary packages are essential to attract and retain outstanding individuals.

“Under the present vice chancellor’s leadership, Durham has achieved UK top five and a world top 100 university status, membership of the Russell Group of universities and has shown greatly improved performance in research and education.”

However, Southampton vice-chancellor, Don Nutbeam, received a ÂŁ19,000 rise in benefits, even though the university saw a thirteen per cent drop in undergraduate acceptances.

The news of a large pay rise in come universities, such as University College London (UCL), which awarded its president an extra ÂŁ41,077, has caused a reaction from their student unions.

Hannah Webb, a student officer at UCL’s student union said “It’s completely unfair. The people who allow the university to function are at the lower level: the academics, the cleaners and the support staff. These are the people whose wages have been decreasing”.

Durham University has impressed, however, that the one per cent national pay rise for staff should not be viewed in isolation: “In addition to the national pay rise, many members of staff benefit from an incremental increase each year.”

But as vice-chancellor salaries start exceeding £400,000 in institutions like Oxford University and London School of Economics, there has been a call for increased scrutiny on university executives’ pay.

Some contend that without fair oversight, there is a danger of abuse.

Sally Hunt, general secretary of UCU said that “It is vital that we ensure there is proper scrutiny of vice-chancellors’ pay and pension provision if we are to avoid suspicion of one law for those at the top and another for the rest.”

A spokesperson for Durham University explained that this disparity is due to the fact that “with regard to all other staff at the University, salary negotiations are agreed at a national level. The University and Colleges Employers Association (UCEA) represents HE institutions and negotiates national increases with the trade unions.”

Hunt, therefore, recommends that student and academic staff representatives should sit on the university remuneration committees that determine vice chancellor pay.

Russell group director Wendy Piatt insisted that the salaries of vice-chancellors “reflect their roles leading extremely complex international organisations with annual turnovers of more than half a billion pounds on average”.

Photograph Courtesy of: Durham University