VAT on Private Schools: an alternative perspective 

By Tommi Loke 

Palatinate recently ran a comment piece justifying the levying of VAT on independent schools. Though it raised important points and questions about our education sector, it pretended that the policy was simply a case of right versus wrong. The fact of the matter is that the Labour government, squeezed by surging support by their traditional working class voter base for Reform, has put forward a detrimental policy in the hopes of using class conflict to reignite their flailing popularity. What should become clearer, using facts and figures, is that this policy serves to do more harm than good and is not only unnecessary but also vindictive.

Though a tax of 20% will be levied on independent school fees, Labour estimates that fees will only increase by 10%. This is because independent schools are able to absorb some of the additional cost, reducing the burden on the consumer. This will almost certainly entail a scrapping or scaling-down of full and partial bursary funding. Without this support, children on bursaries, who have significant ability and potential, would be forced to drop into state education, worsening their educational prospects. Furthermore, fee increases of 10% will cause the poorest of fee-payers – those who perhaps forego holidays or take out additional mortgages just to give their children a better education – to likewise drop into state education. So worse-off independently-educated pupils will be harmed most from this policy.

Worse-off independently-educated pupils will be harmed most from this policy

 Additionally, independent schools would likely reduce the scale of their partnerships with local state schools. In the past, this included supporting the training of new teachers, the loaning of teachers to state schools and use of independent schools’ facilities. Independent schools, no longer charitable organisations, are now businesses and will thus become more ruthless and consumer-orientated. So, thanks to VAT, independent schools will become even more exclusive and elite, forced to limit their charitable actions merely to stay afloat.

Given all these harms, one should expect the policy to have a mass of positives. Rachel from accounts says the government will spend “every penny” raised on state schools. Some of this money will go towards training 6500 new teachers. Impressive right? Unfortunately, spread between over 20,000 schools this measure will only increase the number of teachers in each state school on average by the grand total of 0.3 teachers. Whatever impact this has is certain to be diluted and make negligible impact on educational quality. However, there are still some benefits gained through additional tax revenue.

Labour estimates that the policy will generate £1.7bn per year. Taking into account spending required for pupils moving from independent schools to state schools, optimistic estimates by the IFS suggest the policy would raise £1.5bn. Across the UK’s roughly 9,900,000 state school pupils, each pupil will gain an increase in funding of £152. Conservative estimates suggest this is more like £131. This equates to a mere 1.6% increase in per-pupil funding – not even enough to keep up with inflation.

Supporters of this policy claim that to increase funding for state schools there is no alternative to levying VAT on independent schools, but this is risible. Perhaps the supposedly cash-strapped Labour government could locate the funds by cancelling the £9bn or perhaps even as much as £18bn cheque they are set to write to a known Chinese lackey, Mauritius. 

Squeezing independent schools for money will force them to reduce their charitable actions, such as bursaries and state school partnerships

Overall, the VAT implementation is indicative of the Labour government’s vindictive approach to reducing inequality. Squeezing independent schools for money will force them to reduce their charitable actions, such as bursaries and state school partnerships. Moreover, the benefits gained from increased tax revenue are not only severely outweighed by the drawbacks but also comical in scale. From this ideological and spiteful policy, it is clear that the day of the rich lifting up the poor has now ended, and the day of the idiots dragging down the smart has begun.

Image credit: Getty Museum