Valkyrie
AFTER LOSING HIS right hand and left eye fighting in Tunisia, Colonel Claus von Stauffenberg (Cruise) joins a group of German soldiers and politicians in a plot to assassinate Hitler and use Operation Valkyrie to mobilise the Reserve Army to take control of Berlin.
Some of the conspirators want to prevent further loss of life by ending the war, while for others the most important reason for killing Hitler is “to show the world that not all of us were like him.”
Many films telegraph their endings to astute viewers within the first five minutes, but any film dealing with well-known historical events is particularly likely to find itself hamstrung by the fact that everybody knows the ending in advance. Valkyrie touches on events that are better-known than most, and the inevitability of the finale is an obstacle it never quite manages to overcome, even in the thrilling third act.
Predictable or not, the film has attracted a high-quality cast. There is a pool of senior British actors who have become today’s character actors of choice, and it seems like they’ve all somehow managed to find their way into Valkyrie: Kenneth Branagh, Tom Wilkinson, Terrence Stamp, and a cadaverous-looking Bill Nighy.
Sadly, their talents are largely wasted on thinly-drawn characters, with the available screen-time spread over too many conspirators.
It is questionable whether the presence of so many big names derives from a desire to give all the major players in the assassination plot due credit, or merely to get as many bums on seats as possible. Given the depth of character that Bryan Singer brought to the superhero genre with his X-Men films, it is a shame that he wastes so much dramatic potential here.
It is difficult, consequently, to sympathise with many of von Stauffenberg’s co-conspirators. Eddie Izzard (excellent in a rare serious role as a reluctant sympathiser) is perhaps overly harsh when he describes them as “rats jumping from a sinking ship”, but it is hard not to ask why they did not take such decisive action before the tide of the war turned against Germany.
Perhaps, though, such cynical (and potentially disrespectful) questions are the film’s fault, stretching our credulity too far by frequently making it seem as though Tom Hollander was the only man in Germany actually on Hitler’s side.
By far the most sympathetic character, in fact, is Thomas Kretschmann’s world-weary Reserve Army officer, the man given the near-impossible task of carrying out Operation Valkyrie. The story of the people at ground level, having to interpret conflicting orders in the hopes of both doing the right thing and ending up on the winning side, is far more involving than that of the people at the top.
Singer, returning to the Third Reich a decade after he directed Ian McKellen as an elderly Nazi war criminal in Apt Pupil, fortunately rescues his seventh feature film at the death. Earlier moments (a swastika design on the bottom of a pool, a spinning Wagner record) show that he hasn’t lost his visual flair, but it is in the wake of the assassination attempt that he really comes through. Given that the ending is a foregone conclusion, it is to Singer’s credit that he manages to ratchet up so much tension in getting there.
Valkyrie can perhaps be seen as the polar opposite of Singer’s previous film, Superman Returns (proven by scientists with clipboards to be more divisive than Marmite).
His superhero epic, for all the excitement and character work of its first half, was considered a let-down overall for the lack of action which followed; Valkyrie by contrast is largely dull and superficial in the build-up, but its gripping third act is its saving grace.
