Vaccine passports or no vaccine passports? That is the question
Elly Voogt
In July 2021, Boris Johnson announced that, from the end of September, individuals would have to provide proof of being fully vaccinated against Covid-19 to enter crowded indoor settings, such as nightclubs and large sporting events. Yet, the implementation of such ‘vaccine passports’ raises urgent ethical questions.
Vaccine passports are in theory a good way to boost vaccine uptake amongst young people. Recent data suggests that nearly 30% of young people aged 18-29 are yet to accept the offer of a Covid-19 vaccine.
This figure needs to change.
During the vaccine rollout, I have volunteered at a local vaccine clinic. We are seeing a dramatic decline in attendance amongst young people, compared to older generations. Though not all agree, I believe that getting people vaccinated is key for returning to ‘normality’. With vaccine hesitancy being a significant issue, are vaccine passports a measured response to increasing uptake?
Vaccine uptake is integral to return to a ‘normal’ university life in a safer, enjoyable way.
Vaccine uptake is integral to return to a ‘normal’ university life in a safer, enjoyable way. We would once again be able to enjoy nights out, reassured that attendees have made the sensible choice to get vaccinated and that our risk of contracting the virus has been minimised. This would boost the night-time economy and aid the UK’s financial recovery.
Vaccine passports are a stepping-stone to normal life and should help us enjoy life in ways we once took for granted
I would argue you still have a choice, it is just a choice that goes beyond choosing to be vaccinated or not.
However, requiring ‘vaccine passports’ arguably makes the vaccine implicitly mandatory, impacting personal liberties and the concept of choice. Yet, I would argue you still have a choice, it is just a choice that goes beyond choosing to be vaccinated or not. It is instead a choice between being vaccinated or not being able to fully engage with society.
Though minor, vaccination is still a medical procedure, so it is ethically questionable to make such a procedure even implicitly mandatory?
There are arguments that we cannot return to normal if we are still requiring proof of vaccination. Having to provide proof of vaccination is not what we once knew as ‘normal’. Many fear this could deepen the ‘new normal’ the pandemic has produced, violating personal freedoms and increasing state control.
Vaccine passports are not a new idea.
However, vaccine passports are not a new idea. Even pre-Covid, many countries required certain vaccinations to gain entry. For example, Uganda requires a Yellow Fever vaccination certificate upon arrival. Vaccine passports allow people to travel safely, placing less strain on global healthcare systems, and have done for decades.
Vaccination requirements for travel never seemed to cause as much controversy as Covid-19 vaccine passports. This speaks to the politicisation of the pandemic. Surely, we should be doing all we can to halt this virus. But if so, why does it cause so much tension with the personal freedoms we value?
We must recognise that there are some who cannot be vaccinated, even if they wanted to, for example, due to medical issues. For these individuals, vaccine passports could be detrimental. A two-tier society could be created, whereby some vulnerable members of our community miss out on opportunities, such as large events, travelling or employment in certain sectors, through no fault of their own.
Vaccine passports may work well for the majority but will prevent some, for whom vaccination is not an option, from enjoying parts of society they may have once valued. This must be addressed, as it cannot be ethical to prevent some from fully engaging with society because they are medically exempt from vaccination.
Ultimately, I think vaccine passports are a question of social responsibility. What responsibility do we have to others? For those able to receive the vaccine, it is the best way to protect both others and yourself. By taking the vaccine, you are also helping those who cannot be vaccinated due to genuine medical reasons, by helping to reduce the prevalence of the virus within our communities. We are members of a global society and as such we have an ethical responsibility to contribute accordingly.
In this instance, it is as simple as taking the vaccine, if able to, and providing proof of this to protect and reassure others, for this reason, I support the implementation of vaccine passports. However, we must remember that not all can be vaccinated. Any vaccine passport policy should consider this and not marginalise individuals who cannot be vaccinated for medical reasons.
Image: Agência Brasília via Wikimedia Commons.

