The US government shutdown: What it all means

By Sanya Mathur

The threat of a shutdown had already begun in the concluding days of December when the Congress moved towards a stopgap spending bill. This had already caused huge delay on long-term spending decisions following the beginning of the fiscal year for 2018 on Oct. 1 of last year. However, the stopgap only delayed the inevitable as the Republicans and Democrats came to head again on Friday, unable to agree on a new funding bill. Republicans have labelled this the ‘Schumer shutdown’ after Democrat, Chuck Schumer, who, with the help of fellow Democrats (and a few Republicans), led a movement to block the bill that would have kept the government open (temporarily), owing to its controversial commitments to President Trump’s new policies on Security and Immigration.

The last government shutdown in 2013, lasted for 16 days, however, this was the first time that one has occurred with one party controlling the both congress and the white house. The republicans have only have a 51-seat majority in the Senate which means that they cannot pass the bill without Democrat support. The proposed bill did not receive the 60 votes it required by midnight Friday, in this instance it was 50-49. This led to the shutdown, which began on the first anniversary of President Trump’s inauguration.

The Republicans had demanded increased funding for border security, immigration reforms and military spending, including Trump’s infamous border wall. Democrats, on the other hand, are called for protection against deportation of almost 700,000 undocumented immigrants who came to the US as children and protected by the Deffered Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) policy. Moreover, the Republicans have given a six-year extension a to health insurance programme for children in lower-income families but the Democrats want this programme to extend indefinitely. The President had agreed on a deal on their bipartisan compromise but backed away last minute. This was at the infamous ‘sh*thole countries’ meeting.

The shutdown began on the first anniversary of President Trump’s inauguration

In her comment, White House spokeswoman, Sarah Sanders said that ‘The President will not negotiate on immigration reform until Democrats stop playing games and reopen the government.’ The government shutdown was expected to see a mild improvement in the sessions held over the weekend. However, the Senate adjourned without agreeing on anything, leading to a very bleak Monday morning in the US, especially Washington.

So what does this all mean to the US public? A Washington Post-ABC news poll held earlier this week showed that 48 percent American people hold Trump and the Republican Party responsible while only, 28 percent faulted the Democrats. However, according to a CNN/SSRS poll conducted on Friday, ’56 percent overall say approving a budget agreement to avoid a shutdown is more important than continuing the DACA program, while just 34 percent choose the DACA over the shutdown.’ Clearly, the Democrats that had so far held the moral high ground on the ‘dreamers’ program are quickly losing their position simply because now the future of illegal immigrants is contesting with the functioning of the US; it pitching the lives of ‘foreigners’ against American people especially the soldiers. It is expected the popularity of the Democrats will continue to plunge the longer the shutdown lasts.

Trump has been clear on his party’s push for a changed immigration policy – with the DACA programme to be discontinued, the deportation of 11 million undocumented immigrants becoming a top priority, a ban all Muslims entering the country and lastly, the construction of a wall along the border to Mexico. Nonetheless, a majority of the American public understands the absurdity of what their president is suggesting. Support for the DACA is quite strong and many individuals have been working tirelessly to make sure that what Trump pronouncements don’t go through. So, the Democrat decision to hold up the government over this could very well backfire for the policy, quickly turning the people against it.

This shutdown seems petty: politics over policy.

The shutdown ultimately meant that hundreds of federal workers were not allowed to go back to work. Only essential services that protect ‘life or government property’ continued working: such as departments working on national security, postal services, air traffic control, inpatient medical services, outpatient medicine, disaster assistance, prisons, taxation and, electricity departments. However,  none of these ‘essential’ workers were be paid as they worked and there is no guarantee of back-payment for them now that the government has restarted. The furloughing in 2013 had cost the government 24 billion dollars, putting almost 850,000 on leave.

This shutdown seems petty: politics over policy. It put the future of several key policies in jeopardy. Amongst this the fore most consideration would be of the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) that receives 90 percent of its funding from the federal government, a programme which insures almost nine million children whose parents cannot afford insurance but, earn more than the required to qualify for Medicaid. Moreover, neither side made any effort to make basic decisions like pass an emergency budget to fund the military in the meantime. If the shutdown continued it could have undoubtedly affected the financial system creating a period of uncertainty, possibly higher interest rates and definitely lower stock prices, though, with the continuation bill passed recently, the US saw its stock rise once again.

Hence, this shutdown of the US government can only be seen as a lapse in judgement. Congress should have used this opportunity to address the other issues plaguing the US, however,  instead, it seems that the only thing that the two parties can seem to agree on is that President Trump can be held responsible for the shutdown. Had he stuck with the bipartisan deal, there would probably not have been such an uproar around the funding bill which it, at the end, is not really about. Even in hindsight, this entire event will stay as ridiculous as seems right now.

Photograph: Jacob Resor via Flickr