Unravelling the mystery behind university admissions…
MANY STUDENTS ACROSS the country submitting university applications from September 2007 were surprised (and perhaps a little taken aback), upon being asked whether or not their parents received a university education. Although disclosing this information was optional, students were left wondering as to what bearing this sort of information would have upon their pending application.
Pressure on top universities from the current Labour government to “socially engineer” undergraduate intakes to increase the number of students from poorer backgrounds, led Durham University to announce “urgent” action to raise the proportion of students from “lower social classes” within its population.
A whole range of measures have reportedly been used within different universities to increase social diversity, even including a highly advanced points system to distinguish those students that had been poorly taught whilst at school. This has led to accusations that universities are filtering out students from the “middle class”. But what stance does Durham University take on this?
Professor Anthony Forster, Pro-Vice-Chancellor for Learning and Teaching, said in a statement to Palatinate: “The University values the benefits that come from a diverse student population and we are seeking to achieve this through our revised undergraduate admissions policy which was approved by Senate last year.”
The Senate is “the supreme governing body of the University in all academic matters” and has the specific responsibility to regulate “the admission of persons to courses of study”.
Professor Forster went on to say that “unlike many universities, we use academic staff based in our departments to make admissions decisions and have invested in professional training to support this particular approach. We aim to select students who can best benefit from the unique experience that Durham offers and can contribute most to University life, irrespective of their background. All applicants are judged on the basis of merit and potential.”
It is possible to view this revised admissions policy online. It specifically states that “Durham University is interested in recruiting students able to develop both academically and personally within an environment that is attractive to and supportive of an increasingly diverse and international student population.”
It would still seem from reading this statement that it is a seemingly impossible task to distinguish between applicants on ‘personal development potential’, leaving the possibility for other factors to be considered that have not been explicitly stated.
The proportion of state school/private school educated students currently studying at Durham (academic year 2008/2009) is 62% and 38% respectively.
This is higher than in Cambridge where 59% of the student population was previously taught in state funded education. More specifically, in St John’s College and Trinity College, only 38% of students are from state schools.
Durham University has set benchmarks for the future intake of year one state school undergraduate admissions starting at 61% for 2009 and increasing half a percentage point per year up to 62.5% for the 2012 intake.
Durham’s vice-chancellor, Chris Higgins, said: “The proportion of applicants from the state sector is declining each year . . . we need to take action urgently.” This would involve the use of “sharper tools” to attract state school applicants. Already, candidates with high GCSE grades are treated more favourably if they attend poor schools. Such measures may now be extended, according to an article in the Times in January.
In June 2008, universities were told that they could adopt controversial admissions procedures to make lower offers to pupils from struggling state schools because they show ‘greater potential’ than applicants that have been intensively tutored at private schools.
However, Anthony Forster confirmed that “our [Durham] admissions policy does not involve any social engineering or the implementation of quotas according to applicant background (such as school type), nor does it involve making lower offers to applicants according to the type of school they have attended.”
Instead, the University provides a range of outreach activities including Durham’s Institute for Particle Physics Phenomenology’s sixth form specialist talks on particle physics. In recent years, they have also established an annual master class for local schoolchildren. Durham also has one of the most generous bursary schemes in the UK for students from lower income backgrounds. This is to attract more applicants to the univeristy from different backgrounds, rather than giving certain applicants preferential treatment.
Carolyn Fowler, acting registrar at the university said that the falling number of state school applicants could be because the university is ‘incredibly competitive’ to get into and therefore some may believe that it is easier to get in somewhere else.
The main problem at this point would seem to surround the fine line between assessing potential and merit and adhering to set benchmarks for the state sector. Particularly after the confirmation from Anthony Forster that there is “no implementation of quotas”.
Palatinate was able to direct this question at the relevent univeristy department, but unfortunately the response given was not very specific. It merely reinforced previous information that had been disclosed including vague details of the new strategy aimed at increasing the number of applications from the ‘brightest and best students who do not currently apply to Durham University’.
Market analyst firm Caci found just last week, in a study published in The Guardian, that children from the most affluent quarter of families account for a total of 55% of students at top universities. The Conservatives and Liberal Democrats claimed that the study was evidence that the current Labour government had failed to improve social mobility. David Willets, the Tory Shadow Universities Minister, said that the data was ‘hard evidence’ that Labour had ‘failed to widen educational opportunities for people in low income households’.
Whether Labour have failed or not, everyone should be given equal opportunties when it comes to applying for undergraduate positions at university. It cannot be disputed that the job of assessing applicants based on merit and potential is a very difficult task, coming under criticism by some for being too subjective.
Fortunately Durham University does have extensive guidelines and systems in place which are reviewed on a regular basis to ensure that the best students are given the places that they deserve.
Benchmarks set for future intake of year one state school undergraduates:
2009/2010: 61%
2010/2011: 61.5%
2011/2012: 62%
2012/2013: 62.5%
