Unpaid internships are unfair for students

Lightmatter_paperwork-300x200

By Justina Crabtree

As a student, securing a place on an internship can feel like the quest for the holy grail. Phrases such as ʻgraduate prospectsʼ and ʻticket to employmentʼ are bandied about by proper grown ups at many a careers fair, open day or even family dining table.

WeĘĽre led to believe that internships have the magical potential to make our CVs jump out at those with the power to hire us. TheyĘĽre a way of simulating real, career-worthy work, yet all too often donĘĽt yield the most obvious benefit of employment: pay. However, many students accept unpaid internships as a way of catapulting themselves towards their dream jobs, valuing experience over financial gain.

These days, employers are all too aware of this high demand for any kind of contact with the professional world. Whilst interning this summer, I found that the constant stream of hopefuls can be factored into the amount of permanent staff in an office. Companies utilise the unpaid intern workforce to complete the menial yet essential tasks that keep things ticking over. Certain jobs are done once and once only, and thatĘĽs by us, the interns. If these minor responsibilities were to be combined into a single role, it would be most likely that another member of staff ought to be employed, on a part-time basis at least. Cheeky, right?

According to governmental guidelines, those working on a ʻpart-timeʼ or ʻcasualʼ basis – arguably interns, then – ought to be paid the National Minimum Wage. Thatʼs £4.98 per hour if youʼre 18-20, which rises to £6.19 if youʼre over 21. Yet somehow, interns fall outside the minimum wage requirements. Legally, if a placement lasts for a fixed time period no longer than four months, and all work-related expenses have been covered by the employer, they need not be paid. However, advertised positions often fall short of these requirements. Furthermore, interns are usually expected to contribute personally to the organisation concerned and therefore ought to be classed as paid ʻworkersʼ. This makes the circumstances of many unpaid internships illegal.

Clearly, the present situation hits hardest those who canĘĽt afford to work for free. Students not only miss out on wages which may be earned in the period spent interning, but many employers providing standard unskilled jobs such as waitressing or reception work are reluctant to hire those who will be unavailable for several weeks at a time. Furthermore, students living in larger cities like London get an easier deal, as travel and accommodation expenses are reduced.

The unfairness of unpaid internships appears to be an issue that many are content to turn a blind eye to. The economic troubles of recent years means that there simply isnĘĽt enough money in many sectors to pay interns, with permanent staff already feeling undervalued for the long hours they work. The grim truth is that there will always be someone more desperate than we may be, willing to accept a bad deal in the hope that it may lead to an invaluable job offer. Our anxiety for graduate employment was exemplified this August when Moritz Erhardt, a Bank of America Merill Lynch intern, was found dead after working 72 hours straight.

“I can only recommend the Ę»chin upĘĽ approach to aspiring interns”

Fortunately, Labour MP Hazel Blears is fighting for the rights of unpaid interns, describing the present situation as a ʻmodern day scandalʼ. This June, she launched the Let’s Get Our House In Order campaign which encourages all MPs to pay their interns.

Of course, there are plenty of benefits to any kind of experience in our chosen industries. Beyond honing the skills required for a particular job, internships are worthwhile because of the people you have the potential to meet, and the many opportunities that this networking may lead to. Furthermore, itĘĽs a no brainer that those who have dedicated time to interning are far more likely to impress interviewers than those who have no relevant experience.

Itʼs also important to remember that bad days at work are equally as helpful as the good – being propelled away from a particular career because it wasnʼt all you thought it would be is just as important as securing a job for after graduation.

At this point in time, I can only recommend the ʻchin upʼ approach to aspiring interns. There just isnʼt enough funding to go around, leaving many companies far from even thinking about paying their intern workforce. Yes, itʼs frustrating and unfair, but do we really have another option? In todayʼs increasingly competitive job market, there will always be someone willing to complete the same tasks weʼre given for less reward. However, Iʼm putting my trust in the belief that if an internship gets you anywhere, a mere toe in the door towards your ideal career, the hard slog has been worth it. All we can really do is sit quietly with our filing, fact checking or tea making lot, and hope that it will pay off eventually.

Photograph by Aaron Logan