University: the root of religious extremism?
In the wake of the failed Christmas Day plane bomb attempt fears about the radicalisation of students in universities have re-surfaced. The alleged bomber, Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab, enrolled on a mechanical engineering course at University College London between 2005 and 2008. Questions are now being asked as to how exceptional he was.
The accused Nigerian bomber’s ‘Islamic extremism’ allegedly goes back to his time as a student in London, where he was President of the Islamic society in 2006/2007. The UCL engineering department however described Mr Abdulmutallab “well-mannered, quietly spoken, polite and able young man,” who “never gave his tutors any cause for concern”. His predecessor as President of the Islamic Society Qasim Rafiq said he had not shown any sign of violent extremism whilst in London.
This kind of event is not without precedent. Last year two Pakistani students studying at John Moores University in Liverpool were accused but not charged for an alleged terror plot. In this instance the Home Office’s response was to attempt to deport them.
In 2007, the UCU (University and College Union) unanimously rejected government advice for lecturers to monitor campus extremism. The UCU’s general secretary Sally Hunt said that student trust would be undermined by fears of a “quasi-secret service”. The UCU claimed that the measures equated to a continued escalation of the “demonization of Muslim and other minorities”.
The disclosing of Abdulmutallab’s academic history raise security concerns within multi-faith University communities. Sam Dale, Deputy Academic Registrar, assured Palatinate that there is “no evidence that the presence of extremist groups on campus is an issue at Durham University”.
“The University have already done a lot of work to ensure national guidelines are followed on promoting good campus relations and on ensuring staff and students can live, study and work in a respectful and tolerant environment”.
Nevertheless, the issue of extremism remains deep-rooted. Durham University is represented as a member of a local partnership between the police, Durham County Council, health organisations and educational providers who meet on a regular basis to discuss the strategy for averting extremism and responding to other related issues.
Such actions potentially undermine the liberal values of diversity of expression and call into question the extent to which students can express their beliefs without fear of reprisal. The University is keen to strike a balance in respect to this, with Dale claiming “the University embraces freedom of expression and challenging debate, but it does not condone any extremist views”.
A similar stance is advocated by Durham Student’s Union in its Equal Opportunities policy that provides a framework for it to pursue its duties to promote good campus relations and positive attitudes between people of diverse backgrounds in all its activities. The policy forbids discrimination on religious grounds, threatening penalties of lifetime bans from the DSU and University action under the Respect at Work and Study act.
President of Durham Student’s Union and Equal Opportunities Officer, Natalie Crisp, accepts there is no room for complacency with extremism and is working in partnership with the University and the Islamic society “to ensure there is a full and frank dialogue between us all and to prevent backlash against students in light of current events.”
“Durham Islamic Society like others around the country, have been and continue to be heavily involved in interfaith work and hosting positive and interesting debate, both within the society and with others and I have full confidence in them.”
