University reform: first class ideas or a failing strategy?
By Isaac Johnson
Rishi Sunak last summer promised to “get tough” on universities that do not provide students with economic prosperity. This, along with the recent changes to student finance leave many wondering if Mr Sunak’s intentions are genuine and justified, or if these statements can be linked to an election strategy focused on division.
Starting this September, new undergraduate students will have to pay back their student loans for 30 years, 10 more than previously required, and will begin repaying their loans with a salary of £25,000, two-thousand pounds less than before. These changes significantly reduce the taxpayers’ burden for higher education, from 44p for every pound spent to just 19 pence.
Supporters argue that the reforms tabled for universities are not a part of any election strategy and are instead genuine attempts to make higher education more beneficial to students by ensuring that the cost of their degree will be compensated via higher earnings in their career.
For some time, it has been clear that educational reform has been wanted by students and universities alike. Increasing dependence on international students, the challenges of online learning through the Covid-19 pandemic and the current marking boycott have left all involved feeling dissatisfied. The proposed changes, which may include phasing out low-earning degrees, present a better deal for the taxpayer and could allow for a reallocation of these funds towards high-earning degrees or those of increased social value. This may allow more doctors and nurses to be trained or the introduction of reduced fees for the courses central to the economy.
The changes show a lack of recognition of the intrinsic value of further education beyond contribution to the nation’s GDP.
Some have recognised that the changes to student finance will disproportionately affect those from poorer backgrounds, unable to fund a government labelled ‘low value’ degree if they so wished through study abroad or private courses. The changes show a lack of recognition of the intrinsic value of further education beyond contribution to the nation’s GDP. The skills taught, friends made and experience lived contribute to the creation of rounded people who do more for society than increase in tax revenue. Even so, as Dr. Richard McCulloch told The Mirror, the arts sector significantly contributes to the national economy, to the tune of £109 billion in 2021.
Some would argue that this is a necessary step to reduce public spending amid a tough economic climate. With public services being dangerously underfunded, the cost-of-living crisis and current inflation pushing families to the brink, reducing funding for higher education appears to be a part of a series of pragmatic steps taken by the government to try and improve the economic situation. This move is an attempt to try and protect students from being saddled with debt yet have no material increase to their job prospects. Mr Sunak will also be hoping this move will aid the government’s efforts in halving inflation and growing the economy. Current polling suggests that delivering on this, and his five pledges as a whole, will be crucial for the Conservatives hope of general election success.
Reducing funding for higher education appears to be a part of a series of pragmatic steps taken by the government to try and improve the economic situation.
Opponents of these policies may see this reform as hollow, motivated by the knowledge that students do not majoritarily vote Conservative and that their turnout in elections is often low. On balance it is unclear whether the intention for reform is genuine, or whether universities are simply another battleground in the Conservative attempt to divide the UK electorate along the lines of a brutal culture war. Whilst his words speak of grand reform, few believe that strangling subject choices is the answer to a struggling higher education sector. Mr Sunak tries to unite a party plagued by scandal through demonstrating pragmatic governance; all the while attempting to display Labour as the party of chaos who would be unable to lead. Few are confident that his reforms would solve the issues within universities, but only time will tell if his wider strategy saves his own job.
Image: NazWeb via Wikimedia Commons
