University is a positive choice – a reply to Dave Richards’ pessimistic view of institutional education
One comment writer had a pretty tough time at school. Last week, Dave Richards poured his heart out to Palatinate readers, describing the “throbbing ache” he felt when sitting in a classroom. Richards recalled his “ghostly memories” of an experience he claims separated him from his true nature.
Richards then managed to move beyond dark recollections to launch an attack on the institutional education process. His conclusion? That all those hours in the classroom were intended to turn him into a passive, obedient worker, suitable for filling a gap on the production line.
Indeed, Richards believes this has happened to all of us. The curriculum, instead of fostering independent thinking, has acted as a smoke screen for the system of forced learning that ensures we become emotionally dependent on authority.
So, we learn small bits of useless information and compete with our peers to see who can recall the most in an examination. We are then given a place on the production line based on how well we do.
It’s fair to say that Richards’ experiences are congruent to the theories of some notable academics. In 1992, John Gatto published Dumbing Us Down, arguing that mainstream education systems had a “hidden curriculum” intended to enforce the transmission of norms, values and beliefs decided by figures of authority. He believes that the curriculum makes us more likely to favour democracy, helping us to avoid radical political systems like anarchism or socialism.
But it’s also fair to say that boring books don’t sell. So had Gatto written, say, a history of American education policy, he wouldn’t have sold 150,000 copies. This isn’t to suggest that Gatto’s motives were purely monetary: he won New York City’s Teacher of the Year award three times before giving up to become an author in 1991. But it is a known truth that radical, counter-intuitive books will always win more publicity than any other.
Academic intrigues aside, Richards’ position can’t be left unscrutinised. Firstly, he has painted a wildly inaccurate picture of modern education practices. This seems hard to do given his first-hand experience in a top-flight institution, but he’s managed it nevertheless. He describes the university he attends as totally aligned to ‘the needs of the corporate sector’.
This means that he isn’t free to pursue his own interests because he’s too busy being instructed on how best to fit into the production line. Admittedly, in the last few weeks of term summatives always capture a few slaves. But for the vast majority, university life isn’t defined by the library or laboratory. Rather than a life dominated by corporate instruction, students thrive on Saturday walks with the Hill Walking Society, rehearsals for a college musical and Wednesday afternoons at Maiden Castle.
But what’s so wrong with wanting a good job? Richards describes the world of work as a production line: a cosmos of obedience and marginalisation. This just doesn’t fit with the freedom of choice available to those who have persevered with education, and the subsequent satisfaction they gain from doing a good job well. Is a Durham graduate using their experience of working with DUCK to start up their own charity part of the ‘production line’?
Is a committed Union Society debater who goes on to enter Parliament evidence of obedience and marginalisation? Everyone who leaves Durham finds more open doors and greater life choices. Education fosters individuality.
Richards’ thoughts on tuition fees are attention-grabbing but unconvincing. They are, he argues, a commodity: a calculated financial investment for one’s corporate future. In paying out money early, we have a greater chance of positioning ourselves further up the production line later on. Does this match up to why you came to Durham?
In part, it should. You weighed up your options and decided university was worth spending £3,145 a year on. Next year, you’ll pay £3,225. But your decision didn’t rest solely on forecast accountancy.
You thought Durham was an amazing place, the Wear being slightly more attractive than the M1. You wanted to meet amazing people, and you have. Your friends are interesting, funny and caring: without them Hound would just be a big, noisy, messy room.
And you chose a university which thrives on soul-enriching activities. That’s why your week just isn’t complete without its complement of sport, music, acting, writing, debating and whatever else you’ll always make time for. Education is a lifestyle choice.
