Universities scrutinised by Office of Fair Trading
Amal Vaidya
The Office of Fair Trading (OFT) has opened an investigation into students’ consumer rights and the competition between universities.
The review comes after the sharp increase in tuition fees and changes which allow universities to have more control over the numbers of students they recruit.
The changes were made in order to increase the choice that students have and drive competition between them, yet there have been claims that the desired results have not materialised.
The OFT want to investigate the quality of service provided and how universities compete between themselves for students.
They will also assess how changes in funding effect the way that universities can be regulated.
A report from the Higher Education Commission criticised university regulation as inadequate. The report mentions that, due to higher student fees, universities are less reliant on teaching grants.
Universities do not have to abide by the regulatory conditions that are attracted to such grants and the ability to regulate them is reduced.
The OFT will also investigate whether universities provide good value for money, a major concern for students, especially after the fee rise.
A recent report from Which?, the consumer group, showed that on average, British students work for 30 hours a week, which is less than the European average.
A third year lawyer said that his contact time is “ridiculous” compared to the hours per week a law student at King’s College London receives. He spends on average three hours weekly in lectures or tutorials, and said that:
“There is only so much you can do in terms of self-study when you have minimal feedback for things like essays.”
There is also a disparity in the contact hours for students studying different subjects and across different universities. In some cases, students are receiving as much as half the teaching time as those in other institutions.
According to Bahram Bekhradnia, director of the Higher Education Policy Institute, the country is “short-changing our students in this respect.”
He also commented that “there is no sign that as students pay more they are receiving more for their money.”
However, a final year classicist from Van Mildert said that the few contact hours she received were “intense” and informative.
She added that “for important things, like dissertations, we get all the supervision we need,” though not necessarily in a formal tutorial or workshop.
The Which? report also included a poll showing that almost a third of first year students, who were paying £8000 or more, felt that their courses did not provide value for money.
It is hoped that the report will encourage universities to be more open and engaging, and provide new information for students.
Toni Pearce, president of the National Union of Students, said: “It would be useful to have an external view of what is working well, and in the best interests of students, and what may need some reform.”
The OFT will also ask whether the information provided by universities allows students to make an informed choice about their application choices and how well universities handle complaints.
Clive Maxwell, OFT chief executive, said that “We want to ensure that choice and competition between universities play a positive role in underpinning their success in future, and encourage students, universities, employers and others to respond to our call for information.”
Photograph: Durham University

