Unelected and unrepresentative: Britain’s broken Parliament

By Meg Thomas

In an attempt to reform one of Britain’s many archaic systems, Prime Minister Kier Starmer has introduced a new House of Lords reform proposal. The bill would phase out the remaining 92 hereditary peers in the upper house – that is, peers who inherited titles from their parents. Lords who would see the door would include Lord Attlee (grandson of former Labour Prime Minister, Clement Attlee) and the Duke of Wellington (whose great-great-great-grandfather defeated Napolean at Waterloo in 1815). The UK is one of only two countries with a hereditary element to its Parliament, it is time for us to catch up. Britain is practically begging for this legislation; we need to move past the bygone era of inherited privileges and wealth in order to have any attempt at a meritocracy. The question is – are Starmer’s proposals radical enough? Do they get to the root of Britain’s problem with preposterous class divides? 

It is clear that the House of Lords, in its current form, has little place in a modern Britain. An unelected chamber has no accountability to the British public. Needless to say, a chamber that has an average age of 71 and is 57% privately educated does little to represent Britons who are eager for social mobility. Indeed, the Lords represents a time of stiff social status, impossible to escape if you did not win the lottery of birth. It is a good move for the government to be seen wanting to reform this institution, with 55% of Brits being seen as in favour of an elected upper house. 

The governments proposed bill very simply would phase out the 92 hereditary Lords. The government suggest that this is to ‘create a second chamber more reflective of modern Britain’. So, would simply getting rid of the hereditary elements of the Lords achieve this?

Simply put – no. The hegemony at the top of UK politics runs too deep to be addressed through one change, an entire overhaul of the system is needed. How can a legislative body appointed by the Prime Minister, rather than elected by the people it intends to serve, ever be representative of the public? Certainly, a system based on appointment is outdated and reproduces inequality in British society. We cannot expect the Lords to ‘hold the government to account’ when the government put them there in the first place!

Patronage is a system too easily abused, with pals of PMs getting legislative power rather than experts qualified for the task. For example, the ‘Resignation honours’ list of ex-Prime-Minister Boris Johnson included his ex-press secretary as well as his director of communications. A House based on an appointment has no democratic legitimacy to make political choices nor does it reflect the diverse nature of Britain today. Instead, it is only capable of upholding the status-quo and reproducing the ideas of PM’s gone-by. 

Parliament needs an upper house to keep the Commons in check and nitpick legislation, so what is the answer? It is commendable that the government has pushed for this reform, it is a push in the right direction. However, Starmer still needs to go further on this legislation. It is clear that an unelected body is outdated, the British people deserve a say in who legislates in their name. An elected body of experts is needed. Imagine the legislation that could be delivered by a diverse range of industry experts, who have a mandate given by the people. This could include doctors, teachers, CEO’s, heads of charities, religious leaders  rather than the friends of  the political establishment. Truly radical House of Lord’s reform would signal a new era in Britain. It would be a wave goodbye to old boys network, welcoming in an age based on knowledge, hard work and diversity. 

Image: UK Government/ Wikimedia Commons