Uncertain horizons for free speech in Argentina

Ley-de-Medios

by Nicolas Freeman

Argentina has had a lot of bad press lately.

First, for the expropriation of Spanish energy firm Repsol’s subsidiary YPF last Spring, effectively re-nationalising the company, which had been sold off under a previous government. Critics pointed out that this move followed the discovery of huge shale oil reserves, and that the 57% of YPF shares seized amounted to a ‘theft’ of $10 billion’s worth, which Repsol is demanding in compensation.

Following that, when the Argentine military flagship La Libertad was detained in Ghana in October, as part of a court order obtained by creditors NML Capital, who are seeking to extract the $1.6 billion they claim is owed to themafter Buenos Aires reneged payment on over $100 billion in sovereign debt in the 2002 economic crisis.

Most recently, after the latest wave of protests on the 8th November, when thousands assembled across the country to march against the government’s strict currency restrictions and runaway inflation, estimated to be as high as 30%. The International Monetary Fund is currently threatening Argentina with censure or even “compulsory withdrawal”from the institution unless it provides accurate economic data. At the moment the country’s official figures are thought to be at best highly selective, or at worst, outright fictional.

President Cristina Fernández de Kirchner is blunt about who is to blame. Her only comment after the ‘8-N’ protests was to dismiss the record numbers as representing unpatriotic sectors of the middle class seeking to buy dollars, not the interests of the nation as a whole. However, despite self-stated comparisons to Evita and the legacy of her deceased husband, past-president Nestor Kirchner, two landslide election victories and an amendment to the Constitution permitting her to run a third time in the works, it looks like her Icarus moment is soon to come: the 7th of December, to be precise.

The 7th of December is the date that articles 45 and 161 of the controversial Audiovisual Communication Services Actare set to come into effect, as a court injunction against them expires. Article 45 requires that every media company obtains a broadcasting license from newly created communications regulator AFSCA, and limits the number of cities in which cable companies can hold such licenses to 24. Article 161 establishes a punitive procedure to “divest incompliant companies of their holdings”. Argentina’s largest media group, Clarín, has over 240 cable broadcasters, and may lose many of them starting from Friday. The stated aim of the law is to promote ‘a plurality of voices’ through statutory protection of local media against competition from monopolies. Clarín claims to support this principle, but disputes that AFSCA will be independent of the government in its application of the rules. Rather than bolstering free speech, Clarín worries that these particular provisions will provide a trojan horse for partisan plans to dismantle the voices most able to stand up to abuses of state power. Clarín has had much international support, with the Global Editors Network labeling the move an attack on free speech, the World Association of Newspapers and News Publishers rushing to their defense, and the Inter-American Press Association declaring an urgent “press freedom mission”to Argentina.

If the government backs down and nothing happens on the 7th of December then President Fernández will face the danger of looking ridiculous

Comparisons were drawn at the time with Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez’ media policy, which has supported giving prison sentences for the “abusive exercise of freedom of information and opinion”, shut down over 32 radio stations since 1999, and forced opposition television channel Globovision to flee the country in order to avoid arrest on charges of conspiracy. Last year the University of La Plata honored Mr. Chavez with its Rodolfo Walsh Journalism Prize. President Cristina Fernández made an appearance, embracing her close ally and lauding “his unquestionable and authentic commitment” to press freedom. The now newly-elected Hugo Chavez is also the proud recipient of the 2004 Al-Qadhafi International Prize for Human Rights (both leaders condemned the 2011 Nato-led military action in Libya).

The Guardian’s Roy Greenslade estimates that Fernández’ regime already controls 80% of the national media through direct and indirect means, in particular by funding ‘advocacy journalists’ to throw mud at the opposition, and the preferential allocation of advertising contracts. In 2010 the government became the largest net advertiser in the country, spending approximately $279 million in mass media messages that year. According to government critics, this makes many private media companies financially dependent on state monies, enabling Fernández’ regime to exert a great deal of influence over editorial policy by threatening to revoke or withhold contracts should the coverage of government affairs appear negative. Further limiting Clarín’s reach with the new law would give a decisive advantage to the President, consolidating control of the national media narrative to her favour.

If the government bulldozes ahead on the 7th December it is possible that Clarín could become a symbolic rallying point for all those discontented with the regime, especially its sizeable readership, signifying a last stand against the government’s isolationist approach. An approach which has been criticised as typical of yet another selfishly short-termist junta, beginning with national debt denialism, unrestrained public spending, and tight import controls, and culminating in a brand of extreme economic protectionism that has terrified potential investors away. Taking these policies together, there are many that envision another economic collapse to be on the horizon, and freshly invigorated protests across the country could be the spark that illuminates Fernández’ fragile illusion of financial solvency, turning the tide of public opinion against her.

December is also the month that a large portion of Argentina’s restructured debt is due to be paid, which the government has recently announced it is seeking to re-negotiate, or else be forced to default. On top of that, the government is slogging through its appeal of a New York judge’s ruling that it is obliged to pay the $1.3 billion it owes to ‘holdout’ creditors: those that did not accept the original post-crisis debt restructuring. The New Year is likely to herald very gloomy economic tidings indeed.

If the government backs down and nothing happens on the 7th of December then President Fernández will face the danger of looking ridiculous, once again portrayed as being all bark and no bite, railing against the same imaginary international conspirators behind the La Libertad fiasco (still in Ghana) and YPF’s financial failures, having lost 70% of its market value since expropriation placed it in her hands. Very visible cosmetic surgery and repeated refusals to give press conferences have already given Fernández a reputation for megalomania, and the once popular image of the poor widow finishing Evita Perón’s social legacy may be wearing off. However, the President needs a victory, and Clarín Group provides the obvious nemesis to grant her that pivotal change in fortune.

For the journalists caught in the crossfire, these are dark days. Argentina’s rankings on the Press Freedom Index and Transparency International Corruption Perception Index have dropped in recent years, now in 47thand 102nd place, respectively, and if this latest move is successful, they could fall much further. What follows will no doubt be a suitably pantomime performance for the land of flamboyant tangueros – it could be a page right out of Argentine author Jorge Luis Borges’ Fictions.

Nicolas Freeman is currently studying at the University of Buenos Aires

Image by Diario Movil