UK universities pilot new degree classification
Over twenty UK universities are set to pilot a new method of classifying degrees as part of a national experiment that could see an end to the traditional system of first, second, and third class degrees.
The trial, which runs from November 2013 until July 2014, represents a response to the mounting concern over the rate of grade inflation and lack of detail provided by the current grading system.
This news follows a recent report by Palatinate which exposed the shocking extent of grade inflation within Durham University.
The new system, which is used by US universities, records undergraduates’ modular marks using a sliding scale from zero to 4.25, with students receiving a “grade point average” (GPA) to two decimal places at the end of their course.
However, in this one-year trial coordinated by the Higher Education Academy (HEA), a non-profit company based in York, the GPA system will run alongside traditional degree grades, with a GPA of 4.25 representing a high first-class degree and a score of 3.00 equating to a low 2:1, for example.
HEA has said that the new system, which is being tested at some of the most respected institutions in the UK, including the University of Edinburgh and the University of Birmingham, “could run alongside, or ultimately replace, the existing honours degree classification.”
Earlier this year, Universities Minister David Willets backed the HEA trial, stating that the GPA system “offers greater transparency and focus for both students and employers.”
Sir Bob Burgess, Vice-Chancellor of Leicester University and Chair of the HEA Board, had called for changes to the current system of degree grading back in 2004, when he published a report that deemed the system to be “no longer fit for purpose.”
Indeed, official figures from 2012 show a dramatic increase in the rate of grade inflation, with 61,600 students leaving university with a first-class degree, a figure that has tripled since the 1990s.
Additionally, over two-thirds of students in the same academic year gained an upper-second class degree.
Durham University, however, has not opted to participate in the trial alongside other highly regarded universities.
Michael Gilmore, Academic Registrar at the University, stated: “When a call came round for expressions of interest to take part in the trial, we didn’t have the staff capacity to be involved.”
He added that the University would consider participating in future “if the trial showed that it benefited graduates.”
Aisling Cowell, a first year Law student, voiced her support for the GPA system, telling Palatinate: “Too many people are applying to the same jobs with the same level of degree, making the graduate job market more about who you know rather than your abilities.”
A third year Chemistry student, David O’Farrell, agreed, arguing: “Our current system is extremely vague with too many people getting 2:1s.”
In contrast, Hatty Goddard, a first year Psychology student, struggles to see the need for change, arguing: “We have used this system for 200 years so why should we change it now?
“There needs to be more consistency in the education sector after the raft of changes that have already been introduced by the coalition.”
The HEA’s findings from the one-year trial are due to be published next autumn, with further investigation into the GPA system at another 25 institutions set to begin in the spring of 2014.
Photograph: Durham Univeristy

