UCAS favours private schools

by Lindsay Turner

UCAS has admitted that it unfairly disadvantages students from state schools in its latest review of the university admissions process.

The review claims that pupils at private schools are encouraged to apply earlier, in the hope of improving their chances of gaining conditional offers, and are given more assistance in their application than pupils from state schools.

Students have expressed concern about the short time frame involved in the new system. A second year Castle student fears that finding out whether you have a place at university as late as September or October could prove “highly problematic.” The new system would also involve bringing forward the dates of A Level exams by up to six weeks.

Students at private schools are also thought to be supported by families who are more familiar with the admissions process, giving them a further advantage.

The study has led to calls for a complete overhaul of the application process. Under the new proposals, students would not apply until after they had received their final exam results. Students could apply to just two universities, compared to the current system of applying to up to five different institutions.

According to the review, the new system would increase transparency and enable students from all backgrounds to have “more confident and informed applications”, removing the “undesirable divide between those applicants who receive effective advice and those who do not.”

Wendy Piatt, Director General of the Russell Group of universities, of which Durham is not a member, is concerned that proposals might “restrict the ability of institutions to make a fair and thorough assessment of applicants”.

Yet with UCAS research indicating that just 52% of predicted grades are correct, and with fewer than 10% of students receiving three correct predicted grades, the current system is not without its flaws.

Consultation on the proposals is set to continue until 20th January 2012. If positive feedback is received, the new system could be in place by 2016.