Two Lefts Don’t Make A Right: The Arab Spring – Economic Revolution Waiting to Happen?

by Matthew Beebee

It is strange to think that this December will mark the two-year anniversary of the start of the Arab Spring. Yet, close to two years since the revolutions birth, political progress has been slow. Kuwait, Oman and Lebanon implemented government reforms in response to protest; Morocco and Jordan changed their countries constitution. Yemen, Egypt and Tunisia ousted their authoritarian president and have seen elections take place while Libya’s revolution has still not seen political stability ensured. Civil uprising continues against small-scale government reform in Bahrain and the on-going struggle in Syria is clear for all to see.

Perhaps more worryingly, economic progress has been even slower. No government in the Middle East has attempted serious economic reform – with the exception of Lebanon where there has been a 40% wage increase. This is in light of the fact that Middle Eastern economies are distorted and outrage at poor living standards and unemployment played a major role in the first flames of the uprising being sparked.

Governments who have come close to protests, notably Saudi Arabia, have effectively bought off protests by increasing public spending up to 50% at times. Although high oil prices have financed such huge rises, much of the spending has been on public sector wages and subsidies, to the detriment of what little private sector there is.

Subsidies have become a somewhat necessary problem in the Middle East given the hostile climate and the impact on crops this has. Egypt spends over 10% of GDP on food subsidies. These subsidies do come with the price of benefiting the richest subsidy collectors, allowing their largely loss-making firms to stay afloat and distort domestic prices. It has allowed a close connection between state and what little private sector there is; for example, in Egypt, the largest firms have access to 40% of total subsidies.

Keeping big business and the rich onside via subsidies allowed old governments to keep those in high places onside with their authoritarian rule. Despite this ‘cronyism’ being caught out by the recent political change, little has been done to aid the fundamental economic problem in the Middle East – the lack of a developed private sector and free access to global markets.

The Arab Spring’s political protest has made it even harder to forward the economic revolution that is needed. This somewhat ironic given that economic problems caused by substandard living conditions and unemployment, especially amongst the young, were key to the political revolution. The situation is, to put it mildly, not what would could be called ideal to set up business and, more to the point, the income needed to start up a new firm just isn’t there. Even now, the state still dominates the economy.

The Arab Spring’s political protest has made it even harder to forward the economic revolution that is needed.

Despite its favourable geographical location the Middle East is often missed out of economic production by Western firms, mainly to do with poor skill levels, underdeveloped infrastructure and political instability. All this is bad for business. Free-market rhetoric would have us believe that all economic problems can be solved with the trusty three-card trick of privatisation, deregulation and liberalisation. Wholesale free-market reform would overlook the sheer political insanity for this to occur in the Middle East.

The major problem of such policies would be the fear firms would be sold off to the politically connected or attempted in such a way that ensures continued state interference. The potential for Western ownership is viewed with suspicion especially in previous colonial nations. Instead political reform is more viable as a way to open up the economic landscape. New governments must reign in subsidies and state support for old political allies in business and focus on an industrial policy and building projects that meets the demands of the young unemployed.

There is also a regional factor in the weakness of Middle Eastern private sector firms – the failure to develop regional markets. The region’s trade problem is mainly due to its over-reliance on crude oil exports meaning there has been little incentive to develop other markets.

Similarly, unlike Europe, where there is widespread inter-European trade, the Middle East has no need to inter-trade as most of the country’s export the same thing – oil. Oil cannot generate anywhere near the level of jobs needed for young people; manufacturing and service sectors need to be developed in order to meet these job demands.

It is laughable to think that it takes longer to ship goods between two Middle Eastern ports than it does between the Middle East and America. This is due to the trade bureaucracies as a consequence of the largely state-led economics. A lot of the problems of inter-state trade in the Middle East are self-inflicted; economic barriers are based on political and religious hatreds more than any genuine economically protectionist concerns.

More trade can only bring benefits to an area that desperately needs it; larger markets enable firms to be more productive and efficient, increase foreign investment and allow easier adoption of new technology. Open trade would begin a process of change away from state-led economics and create more lasting and stable political revolution.

Photograph: Parliamentary copyright images are reproduced with the permission of Parliament