TV Watch: Restless

by Naomi Ellis

Despite its clear aesthetic appeal, there is something lacking in Restless. The BBC’s intense TV adaptation of the thriller of the same name by William Boyd, for some reason or another, refuses to allow the viewer in. All the right elements are present. Old and new British acting talent, a time shift between the 70’s and wartime; and an intriguing premise laden with the discovery of familial secrets. However, none of this comes to any kind of real fruition and I found myself disappointed.

I felt alienated by the characters, who although interesting from the outset soon dissolved into empty, melodramatic types. Michelle Dockery attempts to make a leap from the unconvincing, callous Mary of ITV’s Downton Abbey, (“I do love you terribly, Matthew.”) to an apparent hippie-cum-academic cynical single mother of the Seventies, and to no avail. Her character spends the viewer’s precious time using those eyebrows to frown pensively in the distance. Ultimately Downton Abbey has a hold on her that she has yet to wriggle free of. Her accent is quite a feat: confusingly strained, her cut-glass English sounds oddly muddled with a kind of accentual nonchalance that is anything but befitting of a bell bottom wearing radical PHD student at Cambridge. Dockery is flat, but she does succeed in contrasting the seeming encroaching lunacy of her mother’s ominously paranoid behaviour.

Like mother, like daughter the ever-sinister Charlotte Rampling (how could we forget her fittingly heartless turn as the demon headmistress in Never Let Me Go) also somehow leaves something to be desired in her role as the protagonist, Eva. At one point or another we realise that our parents had lives before our existence but Eva’s past is one that shocks her daughter to disbelief. Not everyone can say that their mum worked as a spy amongst the shady subterranean workings of World War II. Unfortunately in spite of her seemingly calm revelation of her dramatic past and subsequent desire for help to protect herself from the threat posed on her present life, the elder Eva comes off hollow and mildly boring.

As the script trundles along the programme as a whole seems to want originality.

Rufus Sewell proves lukewarm acting isn’t just reserved for the female cast. The only memorable role of his, relatively speaking, that I can bring to mind is that of Kate Winslet’s handsome and thoughtless boss in that terribly cliché Christmas film (such terms are sadly synonymous these days) The Holiday. His cold blue eyes still say ‘I will hurt you, don’t trust me’ however inaudibly to the women that for some reason desire him. He appears as the elusive Lucas Romer, head honcho of the AAS whose primary role is to feed the worldwide press fabricated stories that have important reverberations on the war as a whole. Romer’s subsequent relationship with Eva, his protégée, seems forced and unrealistic, like much of his role in the programme as a whole. Although, given the snippet of the final episode it appears he is the pivot on which the life of elder Eva swings.

Yet, there is a vestige of redemption found in the form of the actress Hayley Atwell who plays the younger Eva, who finds herself becoming a naive wartime spy in the wake of her brother’s death. We see the confusion, mistrust and pervasive dominance of the unknown in the war through this young Russian’s eyes.

Correct me if I’m wrong. Am I missing the crucial need for everyone to be hollow and lacking in any kind of depth of characterisation? Is this some sort of attempt on the role of the director to elucidate the idea of the unreliable nature of relationships within the war and the … I think not. As the script trundles along the programme as a whole seems to want originality. Though at times stylistically Restless is era-appropriate, with some beautiful instances of wardrobe and landscape, I felt the programme as a whole was devoid of emotion and just not quite as engaging as it should be given the actors and the novel itself.

Perhaps the introduction of Michael Gambon in Part Two will absolve the programme from its sins and finish this extended programme on a high. Then again Michelle Dockery might just say ‘Mam’ a few more times and leave us all even more lost as to why the BBC thought it wise to cast her in anything other than a stale period drama. I won’t hold my breath.

Photograph: BBC