TV Review: Homeland, Series 4 Episode 1
By Alex Cheah

There’s a moment early in the first season of Homeland that sticks out as epitomising what was brilliant about it. Through the CCTV cameras, secretly and illegally installed by volatile CIA analyst Carrie Mathison in to the Brody household, we see Nicholas, freshly returned from years in Middle-Eastern captivity, give up on trying to sleep in his bed and go and sit in the corner of the room, his head resting against the wall.
The dynamic between Mathison and Brody was the cornerstone of season 1. It evolved from acidic suspicion through cathartic lust to mutual co-existence and co-dependence – possibly ‘true love’. But regardless of periodical semantics, it was the consistently underlying obsession and compulsion between the two that lingered on the palate of the audience.
Thematically, inner conflict was central to the show’s propulsion – Brody’s love for his family against his desire to avenge the crimes of the ‘homeland’ in which he grew up after his terrorist indoctrination, and Carrie’s dilemma of either impulsively following her gut instincts or shutting up, taking her medicine and doing as she’s told. It made for gripping psychological drama, a reflection of public anxiety, suspicion and paranoia over the fine lines of foreign policy and national security which are also being experienced at this very moment in civic consciousness.
But the third season regressed into a perfect storm of bureaucracy, incapacitation and inevitable disaster that was inflicted upon its characters rather than chosen by them. A comparison between season 2’s pulsating scenes involving Brody wearing a suicide jacket inside the underground bunker of the president and the mind-numbing courtroom scenes as well as Saul’s sober shrug in apology to Carrie over his inability to save Brody in season 3 elucidates this authorial diversion.
I was left speechless by the tectonic finale of season 2, as the writers contradicted the momentum they had built only to replace it with another piece of devastating upheaval. But this move turned out to be a phyrric victory. The fallout of the conclusion of the second season meant the breaking up, at least geographically, of Carrie and Brody, and the writers were unable to compensate for the gaping hole that this left. Season 3 saw Brody in Caracas drug dens, his daughter Dana fitzpleasure-ing away from a mental institution in a Cadillac, an underused F. Murray Abraham as a slippery CIA bad-cop, and the addition of a couple of baddies. But this was whistle-stop storytelling, and it meandered to another climactic ending which put both Brody and the series out of its misery.
So Season 4’s premiere, ‘The Drone Queen’, felt very much like a reboot. With anthology series’ like American Horror Story and True Detective in vogue, Homeland too decided to somewhat start afresh with new characters, new settings, and very little carry over from previous narratives. The opening scenes of Sunday’s episode were markedly engaging. The studious, methodically claustrophobic reintroduction of a newly mechanised Carrie (which will, most certainly, violently de-rail in due course) was stylistically satisfying and ‘The Drone Queen’ cake was a subtle reproof of Republican jingoism.
By choosing to shift the focus on to a survivor of the attack, who also happens to seem fairly westernised (by the way he dresses and his free-living at university), the show appears to have decided to humanise itself again. A young, educated man seeking personal vengeance, or even just getting mixed up with the CIA, could prove a complex and compelling character. Unlike the faceless jihadist crackpots of season 3, he probes enquiry over the implications and consequences for innocent people caught in the crossfire of a problematic area. This is, alongside the reliability of source information, a return to the ‘fine lines’ of modern foreign policy referred to above. It would have dented the patriotism of American viewers when the aggrieved lieutenant who carried out Carrie’s orders lambasts her and her CIA colleagues as ‘f***ing monsters. All of you’. This is all promising.
So, it’s early days, but Carrie’s in the brown stuff again. And, so it would seem, Saul will be around to help mop things up. Despite these familiar circumstances, when Quinn smiled knowingly, sympathetically in response to Carrie’s question of why he chose not to join her in Kabul, it suggested that season 4 of ‘Homeland’ may return to a cerebral, philosophical approach to espionage drama. However, the balloon of optimism was tersely pricked by the penultimate scene. The mob-killing of Sandy (thanks to the chance blocking of a road in central Islamabad by what seemed to be a circus truck) was simply a continuation of the headless chicken of death and disaster that was season 3. Carrie, of course treats the brutal death of her colleague as if she’d stepped in some dog poo. Quinn asks the question on behalf of the audience: ‘‘what is wrong with you?’. But Carrie’s capitulation from a magnetic rebel led by her ethical compass to an irresponsible force of destruction lost in the moral wilderness is a discussion for another day. Poor Claire Danes is probably as confused as the rest of us. For now, by all accounts, the jury will be out on this troubled show for a while.
Homeland airs Sunday nights on Channel 4
