TV Review: Broadchurch, Series 2 Episode 1

By Florence Cook

Image: ITV
Image: ITV

On Monday night ITV’s Broadchurch returned to our television screens with its second series in what should have been a blaze of glory after its fantastic success at last years BAFTA television awards. David Bradley went home with the Best Supporting Actor gong, the series won Best Drama and Olivia Coleman took Best Actress in a win that was far from surprising, but in every way deserved.

What has perhaps tinged the series’ return was the equally unsurprising failure of Gracepoint, FOX’s adaptation of Broadchurch which matched the original almost exactly in plot but not in ratings. Whilst Broadchurch was commissioned for a second series, Gracepoint certainly was not.

Does this cast a shadow over the new series? I don’t know. It certainly left me wondering whether the writers had it in them to replicate the gem that was the first series of Broadchurch. Perhaps the pressure of the first series’ outstanding success would cause this series to crash and burn. Luckily, based on the first episode at least, my fears were quashed before the first ad break.

From the word ‘go’ Broadchurch Series 2 was right on point. The eerie music was back with a disturbingly familiar quality as all the original characters congregated at a poorly disguised Exeter University Campus, masquerading as Wessex County Court. The first ten minutes deftly reintroduced us to the Broadchurch community with a (huge) dash of emotional tension that had me sitting on the edge of my seat – and that was before last year’s murderer, Joe Miller (Matthew Gravelle), announced to a dumb-struck court that he was pleading ‘not guilty’. This proclamation pretty much had me sitting on the floor, jaw dropped. They had my attention.

Coming from a person who usually watches the television with one eye on my phone this was definitely saying something. I love that Broadchurch has not just gone down a brand new path with a brand new mystery. It probably would have been very unconvincing, forced and lacking in the same emotional depth. Instead we continue to see the harrowing impact that this murder had on the town and its occupants, which although hard to watch at some points, is beautifully written and directed. Now with a full trial to come, we must once again face the case of Danny Latimer.

The other storyline for the second series emerged as DI Hardy’s (David Tennant) previous case, Sandbrook, comes back to haunt him when it is revealed that he has been protecting the wife of the chief suspect, Claire Ripley (Eve Myles), ever since her husband walked free. Said suspect, Lee Ashworth (James D’Arcy) has arrived in Broadchurch, standing ominously at the top of a hill – for a reason I am not entirely sure. Regardless, the case of Sandbrook was one of the great unanswered questions from last series and I am sure that I am not the only one who is intrigued to find out more.

As expected, the performances were exactly on point. Certainly Coleman had nothing left to prove and yet she still demonstrated exactly why she won Best Actress last year, and Tennant can do no wrong in my eyes. However, for me the standout was Jodie Whittaker as the afflicted and grieving mother of Danny Latimer. Her breakdown in the graveyard brought tears to my eyes and demonstrated the excellent way this show really makes you empathise with the characters.

Admittedly, this is just the first episode and you never know with television. Maybe this series will end up being a massive disappointment. Maybe Broadchurch should have stayed as a ‘one series wonder’. But somehow, I highly doubt it.