Trump’s misleading historical narratives

By Grace Godfrey

In March, President Trump released the executive order ‘Restoring Truth and Sanity to US History’. He explicitly criticised the Smithsonian Institution, an esteemed collection of political, cultural and scientific museums in the US, as ‘divisive’ and ‘race-centred’. In August, he subsequently wrote to the Institute demanding a full government review of exhibition content, funding, and staff. Vetting museums with the aim of implementing greater ‘content correctness’. 

The Smithsonian Secretary Lonnie G. Bunch has insisted that the museums must maintain independence to preserve historical integrity. However, Trump has placed financial pressure on him if the museums do not promote ‘historically accurate and uplifting’ narratives; around two thirds of Smithsonian funds come from the federal government. Historical accuracy will always be a contested idea; however, it is most effectively achieved when an effort is made to include all historical perspectives. Trump envisions a historical narrative which erases certain voices, seeking to undermine the legitimacy of these people’s values and contributions to American history. 

It is no challenge to assume which voices Trump seeks to erase. The National Portrait Gallery was put under pressure to remove a painting of the Statue of Liberty depicted as a transgender woman. Freedom of interpretation is fundamental to democratic culture; the fact that certain paintings make MAGA zealots uncomfortable does not warrant their removal. Instead, the exploitation of government power to control exhibitions threatens artistic freedom and undermines the basis of democracy. 

Trump dreams of a Smithsonian which installs ‘pride in all Americans’, yet he shows hostility towards cultural representation of minority groups. Historians have argued that these museums are already a point of significant national pride as an extensive display of American social, political and scientific success. But for a complete understanding of the nation’s history, these successes cannot exist without a recognition of illiberalism and injustice. Trump criticises ‘race-centred ideology’ for presenting the US as ‘inherently racist’ and ‘irredeemably flawed’. Trump fears an America which is vulnerable to its flaws and recognises, accepts and overcomes them. It is at this point which its flaws come to define a nation, national ‘pride’ becomes elitist and the US becomes ever more hostile and polarised. 

To create exclusionary narratives is to exclude the values of individuality, multiculturalism and freedom of expression, core aspects of Americanism for so many. To create an American history which glosses over aspects Trump hates to admit is to rob many Americans of their heritage and dignity

In seeking greater control over historical narratives, Trump seeks to define what America truly is. He wants the Smithsonian to promote nothing but ‘Americanism’. However, is this not an ironic rejection of American ideals? To create exclusionary narratives is to exclude the values of individuality, multiculturalism and freedom of expression, core aspects of Americanism for so many. To create an American history which glosses over aspects Trump hates to admit is to rob many Americans of their heritage and dignity. Trump has demonstrated his discomfort with the American Art Museum’s exhibition ‘The Shape of Power: Stories of Race and American Sculpture’, but attacks on such exhibitions this undermine the immense struggle African Americans have undergone to sustain the American economy both during slavery and after. Trump wishes for museums to represent the people and principles he personally aligns with, rather than striving for academic integrity. This is a gross exploitation of museums and their educational and cultural purposes. Every American has a heritage which deserves to be represented accurately and without political interference. 

Trump understands the unprecedented power which control of archives has over historical narratives. He aims for the Smithsonian to inspire ‘generations to come’, a clear recognition of how harnessing history is a way for the President to stretch his influence beyond his constitutional remit. Throughout history authoritarian governments have prohibited historical revisionism, creating a form of nationalism based on misinformation and violence. Trump’s actions are by no means completely comparable to past dictators, unlike Mao’s Cultural Revolution when old culture, customs, habits and ideas were viciously eradicated from society. However, the President’s attempt to use and abuse history for his own power has a familiar and sinister ring to it. 

As with everything with Trump, he loses interest after a week, his policies change or he lies and denies. Whether the Smithsonian Institute does have its exhibitions vetted, its values altered or its funding cut will become clearer in a matter of time. However, it is Trump’s initial intentions which are so intriguing; his determination to attack alternative perspectives to his own exposes his disregard for democratic values and determination to entrench polarisation. Having never visited America myself, I would be keen to explore these museums, but perhaps this article has prohibited any possibility of my visa ever being accepted. 

Image: US Embassy France via Wikimedia Commons