True Crime: A Deadly Passion

By Lucy Hempleman

As a self-proclaimed true crime fanatic, I’ve found myself sucked into the world of illegal big cat traders in ‘Tiger King’, to becoming an internet sleuth with ‘Making a Murderer’, and can binge the latest Netflix true-crime series in a weekend. My friends and I love debating the innocence/guilt of these protagonists; it has become almost a macabre form of social cohesion. This is not, however, a particularly niche fascination, it’s one shared by most of the general public.

Whilst it is hard to gauge the extent to which people consume these shows due to Netflix’s careful safeguarding of its viewing statistics, the true-crime genre is their fastest-growing. However, the profusion of these shows and the surge in copycat killers has made me wonder where we draw the line between harmless preoccupation and a more sinister, almost sociopathic obsession with murderers.

The latest symptom of society’s fascination with true crime is the publication of Dennis Nielsen’s posthumous autobiography, ‘The Drowning Boy’. Nielsen, or ‘Des’ as he’s become known, brutally murdered 12-15 men between 1978 and 1983. He was recently the subject of a TV series, eponymously titled ‘Des’, which, yes, I did binge-watch in a day. However, this is not just innocent viewing for everyone. The harmless effects of the resurgence in interest with Nielson are visible when one looks at the Murder Auction site, where his typed letters sell for £200 each.

Content like this that glorifies violence against women

I was shocked, perhaps naively, to find that the market of ‘murderabilia’ was a thriving one, in which objects associated with famous serial killers were selling for thousands of pounds. Upon entering onto this ‘murderabilia’ website to research this article, I was disturbed to see a t-shirt on the home page of notorious serial killer Ted Bundy clutching two naked women covered in blood.

The defendants of the true-crime genre have argued that our morbid fascination is merely an evolutionary one. It’s human nature, after all, to want to know how to protect ourselves against predators. Producers of these shows, and even some domestic abuse survivors themselves, have argued that these true crime series allow victims to reflect on their traumatic experiences and heal. Yet one wonders how extremely graphic details of the victims’ dismembered remains are humanising? Frequently, what could serve as an opportunity for empathy, quickly diverges into a morbid interest in the serial killer’s persona.

This is most visible in the film, ‘Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and Vile’, in which Netflix paid millions to hire heartthrob Zac Efron to play the Serial Killer, Ted Bundy, leaving many women lusting over the notorious psychopath. Whilst Bundy’s attractiveness was key in luring women in before brutally murdering them, Zac Efron’s casting was flattering, to say the least. Portraying him as such leads to the fetishisation of murderers and its harmful effects ripple throughout society. When we focus on the charming nature and personalities of these men, studies have shown that women find themselves drawn to abusive men. Content like this that glorifies violence against women is likely to be a contributing factor in the domestic abuse epidemic.

The real onus should be placed on the producers of this media

Another consequence of our overexposure to true-crime is that we become desensitised to murder and violence. Indeed, it encourages the copycat effect, in which the sensationalising of murders by the media results in imitations. Malcolm Gladwell uses Granovetter’s model to explain how people not naturally inclined to violence will participate in this behaviour once it becomes popularised. He looked at school shootings in America to show how the first seven were instigated by men who had severe psychological issues, yet the ones afterwards were carried out by men with no neurological problems. Indeed, the ‘Columbine Effect’, in which the 1999 Columbine School Massacre’s legacy and representation in the media, has inspired at least nine other school shootings, is testament to this. It’s hardly surprising given that most serial killers are narcissists, that they’d seek to replicate the depraved killers that the media valorises.

Reflecting on what has always been an innocent pastime for me, and many others, has left me disturbed by its extremely harmful effects. As consumers, we have a responsibility to watch these shows/films with a critical eye and realise as we sit behind the comfort of our screen that these are real people, and that the trauma is still raw for many of these families. However, the real onus should be placed on the producers of this media who monetise and profit off of the pain of these often-nameless victims. It’s clearly time for a cultural shift in which the media surrounding crime, focuses on the victims, rather than glorifying serial killers.

Image: Giordano Rossoni on Unsplash

Support Palatinate